New Spinning Reel: Quantum Or Shimano?

[whatevrdoumean]

I am looking to get a new spinning reel this year.
1-Quantum PTI-B Tour Edition for $129.00 (Last years model)
2-Shimano Saros $129.00
Of the two which would you all choose and why?
Thanks, Mike

[Sam]

Shimano.

Because I am a Shimano guy.

Both are very good selections and you can't go wrong.

But for me, it is Shimano.

[00 mod]

Add an extra $15

http://compare.ebay.com/like/300614833233?_lwgsi=y&ltyp=AllFixedPriceItemTypes&var=sbar

Jeff

[flippin and pitchin]

Saros. I have three 3000 series. They come with an extra spool which is nice. The 3000 is the same body size as a 2500 series and has the oversize handle. There were a couple on the Flea Mart recently with PICs and looked to be in great shape. They really are a terrific reel. I have to agree with 00mod on the Stradic option.

[Triton Man]

Both are great so I don't think you can go wrong. I did have a rubber part break on my saros though that caused it to bind up bad until I removed it. I have three quantum energy reels and they have worked great. Really like the magnetic bail that quantum uses instead of a spring because the bail doesn't snap close mid casts nearly as often.

[bigfishbk86]

I'd go with the quantum personally.

[jignfule]

I've owned both Brands and for me this is a no brainer, I would go with the Shimano, no doubt.

[Darren.]

Agree with the Shimano guys. I like the looks of many Quantum spinning reels, and even own two baitcasters which I really like.

But for spinning I use two Stradic 1000 FI models. Love the size for bass fishing, brought in some hefty chunks on these with nary a problem. Drag is flawless. Saw no need for 2500 size or above. But that's me. I feel comfortable hauling in a 10 lber on a 1000 FI. I trust the Shimano hands-down.

Not so sure about the new white Stradics, though. The Saros is just a step down from the Stradic, and a solid reel. I looked at them, but ultimately went the next step up.

You won't regret it (the Saros or Stradic).

[ChiCityBasser]

As someone stated they are both great reels and at that price they are even better buys. I'd go with the Quantum personally as I have both a number of the casting and spinning models purchased new and used and have never had a problem with them at all. Despite the abuse of a lack of cleaning at tmes they still perform flawlessly and do everything I ask of them without an issue.

[SirSnookalot]

I'd go with the one that feels better on my rod.