Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Super User
Posted

Hell i have friends that were arrested fishing flood waters off a river. As the water rose they followed it  into a pasture. The land owner called the sheriff, they were taken out of the boat, cuffed, and hauled off to jail charged with trespassing. That was four years ago and it is no closer to being settled than the day it started.

  • Replies 68
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Super User
Posted

Hell i have friends that were arrested fishing flood waters off a river. As the water rose they followed it  into a pasture. The land owner called the sheriff, they were taken out of the boat, cuffed, and hauled off to jail charged with trespassing. That was four years ago and it is no closer to being settled than the day it started.

  • Super User
Posted
You have no idea the can of worms you just opened. Courts, government, lawyers, landowners, water districts, property owners, general public, etc. have been trying to settle this for years.

I'm betting if you do access it from another source and it's situated over private property you will be cuffed and hauled off for trespassing. The courts in Texas and louisiana are full of cases just like this. no one has a clue yet.

FYI, make sure your friend is willing to post your bail when you do try to access it. Have it in writing because he has no clue. No one else does either.

Devil's advocate, But you don't own the water above your property. And I accessed the water by public means and am not standing on your property. I'm floating on public water. ;D

Don't try this in Texas or Louisiana.

  • Super User
Posted
You have no idea the can of worms you just opened. Courts, government, lawyers, landowners, water districts, property owners, general public, etc. have been trying to settle this for years.

I'm betting if you do access it from another source and it's situated over private property you will be cuffed and hauled off for trespassing. The courts in Texas and louisiana are full of cases just like this. no one has a clue yet.

FYI, make sure your friend is willing to post your bail when you do try to access it. Have it in writing because he has no clue. No one else does either.

Devil's advocate, But you don't own the water above your property. And I accessed the water by public means and am not standing on your property. I'm floating on public water. ;D

Don't try this in Texas or Louisiana.

  • Super User
Posted
You have no idea the can of worms you just opened. Courts, government, lawyers, landowners, water districts, property owners, general public, etc. have been trying to settle this for years.

I'm betting if you do access it from another source and it's situated over private property you will be cuffed and hauled off for trespassing. The courts in Texas and louisiana are full of cases just like this. no one has a clue yet.

FYI, make sure your friend is willing to post your bail when you do try to access it. Have it in writing because he has no clue. No one else does either.

Devil's advocate, But you don't own the water above your property. And I accessed the water by public means and am not standing on your property. I'm floating on public water. ;D

Don't try this in Texas or Louisiana.

  • Super User
Posted

If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

  • Super User
Posted

If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

  • Super User
Posted

If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

  • Super User
Posted
If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

EXACTLY! 

If you find the answer then please let me know.  Better yet, find the answer for Florida while you're at it.

  • Super User
Posted
If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

EXACTLY! 

If you find the answer then please let me know.  Better yet, find the answer for Florida while you're at it.

  • Super User
Posted
If a property owners land stops at the water line, which water line? high or low water mark?

Who owns the land under the water out to the center of the creek?

It goes on forever!!!

AND NO, no one here has the answer, PERIOD!

EXACTLY! 

If you find the answer then please let me know.  Better yet, find the answer for Florida while you're at it.

  • Super User
Posted

On Missouri rivers the answer is somewhat clear.  If you are float fishing a river you will pass by numerous private properties.  As long as you put in at a public access you are fine passing down that river past those private properties in the normal river channel.  However, if you beach your canoe and fish from the bank or fish flooded areas of the owner's property all bets are off.  Stay in the river channel and a property owner can gripe and give you a hard time but legally they can't do anything to you in Missouri.  I don't think this same rule applies to putting in at a public access on a creek that leads to a private lake.  I think that is just asking for trouble.

  • Super User
Posted

On Missouri rivers the answer is somewhat clear.  If you are float fishing a river you will pass by numerous private properties.  As long as you put in at a public access you are fine passing down that river past those private properties in the normal river channel.  However, if you beach your canoe and fish from the bank or fish flooded areas of the owner's property all bets are off.  Stay in the river channel and a property owner can gripe and give you a hard time but legally they can't do anything to you in Missouri.  I don't think this same rule applies to putting in at a public access on a creek that leads to a private lake.  I think that is just asking for trouble.

  • Super User
Posted

On Missouri rivers the answer is somewhat clear.  If you are float fishing a river you will pass by numerous private properties.  As long as you put in at a public access you are fine passing down that river past those private properties in the normal river channel.  However, if you beach your canoe and fish from the bank or fish flooded areas of the owner's property all bets are off.  Stay in the river channel and a property owner can gripe and give you a hard time but legally they can't do anything to you in Missouri.  I don't think this same rule applies to putting in at a public access on a creek that leads to a private lake.  I think that is just asking for trouble.

  • Super User
Posted

A can of worms for sure. Riparian law differs by state and that makes it just that more complex. One factor that is often part of the equation is whether the waterway is "navigable." Of course, the definition of navigable is also probably different in each state. However, if there is navigable public water going into, AND out of, a lake, that would make it much more clear. In your case, that doesn't seem to be the case. As mentioned above, contacting your state fish and game agency might give you a pretty good answer.

  • Super User
Posted

A can of worms for sure. Riparian law differs by state and that makes it just that more complex. One factor that is often part of the equation is whether the waterway is "navigable." Of course, the definition of navigable is also probably different in each state. However, if there is navigable public water going into, AND out of, a lake, that would make it much more clear. In your case, that doesn't seem to be the case. As mentioned above, contacting your state fish and game agency might give you a pretty good answer.

  • Super User
Posted

A can of worms for sure. Riparian law differs by state and that makes it just that more complex. One factor that is often part of the equation is whether the waterway is "navigable." Of course, the definition of navigable is also probably different in each state. However, if there is navigable public water going into, AND out of, a lake, that would make it much more clear. In your case, that doesn't seem to be the case. As mentioned above, contacting your state fish and game agency might give you a pretty good answer.

Posted

Why not just ask the property owner for permission to fish the private water?

Posted

Why not just ask the property owner for permission to fish the private water?

Posted

Why not just ask the property owner for permission to fish the private water?

  • Super User
Posted

The best thing to do is to respect the owner and ask permission. I guide a private lake on private land in NC and all the people who have tried to access the lake via the creek have been hauled off to jail.

  • Super User
Posted

The best thing to do is to respect the owner and ask permission. I guide a private lake on private land in NC and all the people who have tried to access the lake via the creek have been hauled off to jail.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Outboard Engine

    fishing forum

    fishing tackle

    fishing

    fishing

    fishing

    bass fish

    fish for bass



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.