Bradford, McCoy, or Tebow

[Tin]

I would have to lean towards Tebow.

[atx_newbie]

I vote for Tebow as well.  I live in Austin, am a huge fan of Colt (and not just because he has the most perfect name that a Texas QB could ever have), but I think Tebow is just more valuable to his team.  He elevates the level of play of everyone else, and picks up any slack out there, like during the SEC championship game.

Of course, Colt is responsible for 70% of his team's offense, so I guess he's pretty valuable to his team too.  Put another way, that's 7 out of every 10 yards that wouldn't have happened without Colt.

[Still a Bigbuckifan]

I would have to say Colt Mccoy. I Think he did a lot with out a lot of help. Tebow has arguably the best backfield in the country with Demps, Rainy and Harvin. And Bradford is good but I dont think he is on the same level as the other 2. The more i think about it the more it seems like a toss up. Tebow did not put up the #'s he did last year and that might hurt him.

[Daniel A.]

I'm going with McCoy. He's done more with less consistently all year. More than likely, Tebow will win though. Bradford and McCoy could end up with splitting votes because they're both from the same region.

[Fisher of Men]

How about the guy with the biggest numbers? Graham Harrell at least deserved to go to New York!

[mattm]

McCoy but I'm biased.  I think he did the most with the least.  Plus, he shattered the record completion % by like 4 points and was his teams leading rusher and passer.  I bet he gets 3rd though.  He is going to be punished by some for not playing the championship week.

If its not McCoy I just hope its Tebow.

[Hookem]

Guess?

[fathom]

gotta go with tebow of nazareth.

all three are good...but tebow's just a different breed.

[FD.]

I would go with Tebow.  If Bradford or McCoy had put up those kind of yards against any teams that actually played defense, then maybe I would vote differently.

[daviscw]

I went with Bradford, but I could see Tebow winning.

[Hookemdown.]

McCoy :

[Catt]

Second Heisman & second crystal ball    

[Hookemdown.]

Second Heisman & second crystal ball

Tebow will probably walk away with the Heisman again. He's a great leader, and probably deserves it. (All three of them do)

Tebow will cry over his trophies on Jan 8.

[5bass]

I think Bradford will take it. Last I checked, he had the best #'s of any of the others. Numbers are a huge part of it, not to mention the 5 game streak of 60+ points, plus they're headed to the NC game.

If Bradford doesn't get it, I think Tebow will.

[Long Mike]

I live in Oklahoma, so I am naturally biased toward Bradford; and he deserves to win it.  That said, I think that Tebow is one of the greatest athletes that ever walked onto a football field.

[5bass]

I think that Tebow is one of the greatest athletes that ever walked onto a football field.

I agree. He's not just an awesome QB, he is a TRUE football player. If they had not lost to Ole Miss, they probably would've just went ahead and shipped him the trophy after the Alabama game and saved everybody else the trouble of going to NY for the Hesiman presentation.  

[Catt]

There are 10 QBs with better stats than McCoy

While Bradford has outstanding stats they were padded by playing weaker teams

Chattanooga 1-11

Washington 0-12

Baylor 4-8

Texas A&M 4-8

Tebow gets his second Heisman & second crystal ball then turns Pro  

[5bass]

While Bradford has outstanding stats they were padded by playing weaker teams

Chattanooga 1-11

Washington 0-12

Baylor 4-8

Texas A&M 4-8

That statement is false.

Against the 4 weakest teams his total stats are

80/107 1179 yds 13 TD's

Against the 4 best teams they played this year (Mizzou, Ok State, Texas Tech and Texas) his combined stats are

106/151 1445 yds. 15 TD's  

[Catt]

How is that false?

That's 4 out of 12 or 1/3 of his schedule was against weak teams  

[deadeye32.]

Harrell not being invited is outragous, and I'm sure if Tebow wins, he's gonna chest bump and punch the presenter in the face, because he's this great "leader" :. My vote is for Bradford.

[zbass]

shawn green, GO HAWKS!!!!

[Still a Bigbuckifan]

Harrell not being invited is outragous, and I'm sure if Tebow wins, he's gonna chest bump and punch the presenter in the face, because he's this great "leader" :. My vote is for Bradford.

I sense the sarcasm but how can you say he's not a great leader.Not only is he a great leader but he's probably the classiest guy in college football. I can say that I'm definitely not a Florida fan but i am a tebow fan.

[deadeye32.]

I'm not trying to say he's not a great leader, cause he is. I just dont like all the antics he does. The Alabama game was a perfect example of acting like a nut and the announcers eating it up as to how a leader should act. Peyton Manning is a great leader and he doesnt act like that. Can you imagine Tebow on Sundays head butting Ray Lewis or Slapping Tank Johnson on the head, They would kill him and so would the offensive coordinator. JMO.

[Catt]

I guess you don't like Brett Favre cause he dang sure acts a fool, it's called having a love far the game. Some of us just show our emotions in different ways.

[5bass]

How is that false?

That's 4 out of 12 or 1/3 of his schedule was against weak teams

Ok, we'll drop Bradford's #'s against the 4 weakest teams and then compare to Tebow's #'s not dropping any games.

Bradford (-4 easy's) 222/335  3285 yds  35 TD's

Tebow (all games)   174/268  2515 yds  28 TD's