Revo S Or PQ?

[eyedabassman]

I am looking at these two only. What would you buy of these two reels?

[skunked_again]

the Revo S and for me its not even close. i could never imagine not being able to get parts for this reel.

[Ima Bass Ninja]

i went with the pq...i've got 4 of them and couldn't be happier.

[central.PA.bass]

There is a post about 10 posts down asking the same question.. 

but i voted for the REVO S.. not even a comparison..

[OHIO]

I voted for the PQ. They are the best reels you can get for the money IMO.

[Goose52]

I voted for the PQ. I do have a Revo S, but I also have 6 PQs...those numbers speak for themselves.

I know that you've been working through your BC reel decision for quite a while now and it's good that you've narrowed it down to 2 candidates. It doesn't hurt to ask for opinions from the board members...but have you had a chance yet to handle both reels yourself. If you could do that, it would help. Both reels are similar in weight and profile for palming but you might just flat like one over the other after you play with them.

Also, have you decided how you're going to use the reel? For instance, the PQ is available in LH and RH in 4 gear ratios - giving you a number of choices from a deep cranking reel up to a burner reel. The Revo S is available LH and RH in only 6.4:1 - a good all-purpose ratio that may suit your needs.

Are you an experienced user of baitcasters? If so, either reel will cast well for you. If not, the dual-braking system on the PQ reduces the learning curve for many people by minimizing backlashes. The dual-braking feature is also very handy in the wind, and also when your thumb might be numb from cold or gloved. A nifty feature.

The Revo S has a drag rated at 24 pounds, the PQ is 10. A higher drag is important to some people...but as was discussed in a recent thread, many people only have their drags set at around 5 pounds anyway.

Both are good quality reels that will give years of service. The Revo has two more bearings than the PQ but those extra bearings are in the handle knobs - not a big deal. It is likely that parts will be available for the PQ for a long time. BPS has sold tons of these now and the parts are in stock at Outdoor World Rod & Reel Repair. Parts would be available from salvage reels as well. And since some of our board members have reported that many of the parts are interchangeable between a Revo and a PQ, if one thought that Revo parts will be available for a long time...then that means that many of those would be available for PQs as well.

Also, be aware that there was a recent change in the Revo S - the latest version has captive centrifugal brake shoes, as does the PQ. However, the earlier model of the Revo had brake shoes that can become detached inadvertently (which of course will happen when you're standing on grass - bye bye brake shoe). If you decide on the Revo, the newest version will have a better centrifugal brake set-up. Be aware that some of the older Revo S models may still be for sale out there.

Then, there's a couple of little differences. I prefer the spring-loaded sideplate release pin of the PQ over the thumbscrew of the Revo - the PQ is easier to remove the sideplate for brake adjustment, especially when your hands are half-frozen. I like that the PQ has a soft touch clutch bar - the Revo is plain plastic.

So, at the end of the day, my advice would be to take in consideration the comments of the board members, but ALSO make your OWN assessment of the differences between the reels, and then select the reel that best fits your needs.

Both are fine reels - either will serve you well.

[*Hootie]

PQ, PQ, PQ, and PQ, and I'll probably buy a couple more soon!!!

[revoman]

Own both - Revo.

[.Paxamus.]

REVO S, I have of the Revo S and 2 PQ's.  They Revo S is a tank, I tighten the drag all the way down flipping and have no problems.  It is a great reel and just bought another one two days ago. 

[FishinTN]

PQ. If drag is a big factor to ya, upgrade the PQ with a carbon tex drag (costs $10.00) catch the PQ on sale, and still is less than a revo-s. I have not had a revo-s, but have had a couple sx's. I prefer my PQ. The dual braking is great. I'm not saying the revo-s or sx is inferior, they may hold up longer than the PQ, but mine are going on season 3 and are fine. I think the PQ casts better all around, and is as smooth to me.

[skunked_again]

PQ. If drag is a big factor to ya, upgrade the PQ with a carbon tex drag (costs $10.00) catch the PQ on sale, and still is less than a revo-s. I have not had a revo-s, but have had a couple sx's. I prefer my PQ. The dual braking is great. I'm not saying the revo-s or sx is inferior, they may hold up longer than the PQ, but mine are going on season 3 and are fine. I think the PQ casts better all around, and is as smooth to me.

the Revo S and the SX are nothing alike.

[central.PA.bass]

Good reply Goose! You should be a spokesperson for the PQ!

[Dockhead]

I have both. Even if they were the same price, I'd go with a PQ.

Nothing wrong with the Revo S I have, it's been with me for a couple of years with no problems. Just think the PQ is smoother, casts better and has stood up just as well as the Revo - if not better.

[Goose52]

Good reply Goose! You should be a spokesperson for the PQ!

Thanks! I don't want to be a spokesperson, but I do believe in the value of the PQ. 

[eyedabassman]

Looks like maybe a draw! Thanks for everyones input. And a very nice post Goose!

[Goose52]

Looks like maybe a draw! Thanks for everyones input. And a very nice post Goose!

Good luck in your decision.

[Bankbeater]

I have had a revo-s now for about three years and I love it.