Carrington Posted February 2, 2011 Posted February 2, 2011 i would say yes, havnt been pleased with mine.
Super User BrianinMD Posted February 2, 2011 Super User Posted February 2, 2011 I have one, an IMX FSR904x. I am not overly impressed with it for the price. If I had my choice I would sell it and get another Dobyns, very impressed with the 2 Dobyns rods I have now.
WanderLust Posted February 2, 2011 Posted February 2, 2011 I have a BCR803 GLX and its easily the best rod I fished... EVER. Rods that are in the same class are also awesome so it depends on your point of view.
Global Moderator Bluebasser86 Posted February 2, 2011 Global Moderator Posted February 2, 2011 I had one and didn't like it very much for how much I paid, could have bought a few St. Croix Mojos or a combo or two for the same price.
Super User senile1 Posted February 2, 2011 Super User Posted February 2, 2011 I don't think the GLX series is overrated. I own an MBR844C and it is a sweet rod. They may be a bit overpriced.
fathom Posted February 2, 2011 Posted February 2, 2011 depends on which loomis we're talking. outside of the cbr series, am not a huge fan of the mossybacks, bronzebacks, gl2's and 3's or any of the other composite models...good rods, but there are a lot of good rods out there that can match their performance. the glx models, however, are still gold standards...in my hands, still not beaten in terms of crispness, lightness, responsiveness and sensitivity. can't speak to the nrx...yet.
esoxangler Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 I have several GL3's and I like them a lot, but do think they are a bit over priced. I think you can find as good or better (St. Croix Avids) for a bit less money.
Dan-K Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 Loomis is outdated and overrated. I have sold all my Loomis sticks and replaced them with Dobyns... I made a wise decision in my opinion.
steezy Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 The GLX series are tough to beat, I have 2 GLX's, they are worth every dollar, I just wish they were split grip and not cork so I'm going to try one of the new NRX and expect the same or better high quality rod. -Steezy
Super User roadwarrior Posted February 3, 2011 Super User Posted February 3, 2011 Hmm... I have a few and like them a lot. However, a well respected member, Bassin Blvd, has stated that a NRX contrasts to a GLX as a GLX compares to a 2 X 4! Back on topic, G. Loomis is the standard by which all other rods are judged. Loomis starts at IMX. Below that series are better values in other brands. I like St. Croix Avids and Legend Elite. Great rods occasionally on sale for tremendous value. I like my St. Croix, I love my G. Loomis. 8-)
Super User Bassn Blvd Posted February 3, 2011 Super User Posted February 3, 2011 I have a BCR803 GLX and its easily the best rod I fished... EVER. Rods that are in the same class are also awesome so it depends on your point of view. What rods have you fished that are in the same class as GLX and NRX? I don't know of too many other rods that are as good or better than the GLX and NRX series.
Super User Bassn Blvd Posted February 3, 2011 Super User Posted February 3, 2011 Loomis rods are definitely not over rated. I'm not sure if I understand what you mean by over rated. The GLX and NRX series are every bit as lightweight and sensitive as advertised. You can feel a bass fart from 20 feet away ;D. Now, I have never used any series under the IMX series so I can't say if they live up to their name, but from what I here, there are other brands that are as good or better than the GL2 and GL3. Do I think the GLX and NRX are over priced based on how they perform? No, but that's just me.
jeb2 Posted February 3, 2011 Posted February 3, 2011 depends on which loomis we're talking. I agree. I have a few GLX Loomis rods. Some are fantastic, like the BCR803's and MBR843. Very sensitive rods. But others, like my BCR804's, BCR852, CR722, not so much. I think there are a select few Loomis rods that are worth the money, but many that are not, at least compared to what else is available.
Super User Alpster Posted February 3, 2011 Super User Posted February 3, 2011 I have no experience with G.Loomis except for IMX and GLX rods. I think they are wonderful and agree with RW that they are rightfully the "Gold Standard". Since Loomis has stopped selling these blanks, all of my customs are now being built on Lamiglas blanks. Ronnie
juicehound Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 idk...i think the GLX series is overrated. i have three of them - MBR843C, 844X, and SJR-782. I just went fishing today w/ texas rigged senkos using the 843 and honestly it was sensitive but not so much more sensitive than my Bass pro shops extreme rod to justify keeping the rod - No i'm not kidding or crazy - I've caught so many on the extreme rod and for a 70$ rod compared to my GLX which i got for an AMAZING price (considering its a glx) of 175$, I don't think the GLX is really worth the ~100& more...I'm sure there are rods that are comparably sensitive to the glx and significantly lighter than the heavy extreme rod that would be somewhere in the middle of those two in price that I would be much more satisfied with than both the GLX and BPS extreme my only question is why everyone raves about the GLX rods - they aren't really special to me at all - only thing i could think of is people telling themselves its the best rod they ever owned b/c they dropped nearly 400$ on it OR (and this is a question for all of you) is there a difference b/t the original loomis rods and those that are made by shimano...b/c that could explain why some love them and some think they are just good rods.
flippin and pitchin Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 The company has gone through a real transformation, LCI, Loomis Composites, Loomis and G Loomis and now that Gary sold his interest it's G Loomis by Shimano. Only a G Loomis owner can qualify if they are overrated, they bought and fished them. I've owned several over the years. I sold them and I think I have found rods that better meet my expectations for what they cost me. I got my money's worth.
Super User tomustang Posted May 6, 2012 Super User Posted May 6, 2012 The company has gone through a real transformation, LCI, Loomis Composites, Loomis and G Loomis and now that Gary sold his interest it's G Loomis by Shimano. Only a G Loomis owner can qualify if they are overrated, they bought and fished them. I've owned several over the years. I sold them and I think I have found rods that better meet my expectations for what they cost me. I got my money's worth. Now? Gary sold his g loomis company back in '97
jeb2 Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 idk...i think the GLX series is overrated. i have three of them - MBR843C, 844X, and SJR-782. I just went fishing today w/ texas rigged senkos using the 843 and honestly it was sensitive but not so much more sensitive than my Bass pro shops extreme rod to justify keeping the rod - No i'm not kidding or crazy - I've caught so many on the extreme rod and for a 70$ rod compared to my GLX which i got for an AMAZING price (considering its a glx) of 175$, I don't think the GLX is really worth the ~100& more...I'm sure there are rods that are comparably sensitive to the glx and significantly lighter than the heavy extreme rod that would be somewhere in the middle of those two in price that I would be much more satisfied with than both the GLX and BPS extreme my only question is why everyone raves about the GLX rods - they aren't really special to me at all - only thing i could think of is people telling themselves its the best rod they ever owned b/c they dropped nearly 400$ on it OR (and this is a question for all of you) is there a difference b/t the original loomis rods and those that are made by shimano...b/c that could explain why some love them and some think they are just good rods. The MBR GLX series is not the most sensitive rod in the GLX lineup. It's claim to fame is that it's a versatile rod that is still very sensitive. The BCR series rods is all about the bottom contact baits, jig and rigs. I have some of each and almost never use the MBR's for bottom stuff. The BCR's are just better at it. But they're less versatile. That's where I feel the NRX's niche is. It combines the sensitivity of the BCR and the versatility of the MBR, at least for much of the NRX lineup. I do agree with others, though, that the brand is being tarnished by Shimano, especially with their warranty and service program constantly changing for the worse the last year or so. And the various quality issues in the NRX line have been just flat horrible. I don't think Loomis is the only game in town, either. There are lots of great rods out there. I have some Dobyn's Extreme sticks that are really great. Shop around and find what works best for you.
Super User roadwarrior Posted May 6, 2012 Super User Posted May 6, 2012 First post and you revive a three month old thread to diss a rod company? Although it wouldn't be fair for a GLX fan to compare his rod to any brand at a $70 pricing point, stating that the BPS rod is on par with a GLX is simply ridiculous. Not a great way to introduce yourself.
Stasher1 Posted May 6, 2012 Posted May 6, 2012 First post and you revive a three month old thread to diss a rod company? Although it wouldn't be fair for a GLX fan to compare his rod to any brand at a $70 pricing point, stating that the BPS rod is on par with a GLX is simply ridiculous. Not a great way to introduce yourself. Actually it's 15 months old.
Super User K_Mac Posted May 6, 2012 Super User Posted May 6, 2012 This is one of those threads that adds no value. Have a specific like or dislike about a certain rod, that may be worthy of discussion; a general condemnation of any brand, esp one that has stood the test of time like GLoomis is just trolling in my opinion. I don't own any Loomis rods-not because I think they they are over-priced, just outside of my budget. While I'm at it: I use inexpensive rods because I have determined what is "good enough" for me. I do not think my Extreme rods are comparable with GLX-they are not, and to say they they are is just silly IMO. To say they are not worth the price to YOU is valid, but it does not mean they are not worth the premium to others. Use what you like and can afford. Tell me why you like them. Anything beyond that has little, if any value, in my not so humble opinion. One more thing: you can condemn changes in warranty if you choose. I think the changes make good business sense. How that plays out will be determined by the market. I'm done now...
juicehound Posted May 7, 2012 Posted May 7, 2012 Now? Gary sold his g loomis company back in '97 yeah i knew it was a while back but didn't know exactly when - does that really matter lol the point is the company is no longer in his hands The company has gone through a real transformation, LCI, Loomis Composites, Loomis and G Loomis and now that Gary sold his interest it's G Loomis by Shimano. Only a G Loomis owner can qualify if they are overrated, they bought and fished them. I've owned several over the years. I sold them and I think I have found rods that better meet my expectations for what they cost me. I got my money's worth. yeah i'm going to find the right rod for senkos and other bottom baits - the 843c is definitely not it for the price The MBR GLX series is not the most sensitive rod in the GLX lineup. It's claim to fame is that it's a versatile rod that is still very sensitive. The BCR series rods is all about the bottom contact baits, jig and rigs. I have some of each and almost never use the MBR's for bottom stuff. The BCR's are just better at it. But they're less versatile. That's where I feel the NRX's niche is. It combines the sensitivity of the BCR and the versatility of the MBR, at least for much of the NRX lineup. I do agree with others, though, that the brand is being tarnished by Shimano, especially with their warranty and service program constantly changing for the worse the last year or so. And the various quality issues in the NRX line have been just flat horrible. I don't think Loomis is the only game in town, either. There are lots of great rods out there. I have some Dobyn's Extreme sticks that are really great. Shop around and find what works best for you. this is very helpful info thanks! i'll have to pick up a BCR GLX for kicks and see what happens- i'll also check out dobyns would the rods w/ the recoil guides add sensitivity for those type of techniques? i would think they would. First post and you revive a three month old thread to diss a rod company? Although it wouldn't be fair for a GLX fan to compare his rod to any brand at a $70 pricing point, stating that the BPS rod is on par with a GLX is simply ridiculous. Not a great way to introduce yourself. not really... - it's my first post and i'm looking for some discussion/clarification on my experience - who are you king of the thread or something? you sure sound like it w/ your reply to my post jeb2 gave me some great info w/o a ridiculous statement/criticism of my first post, as did the others but why couldn't you? also i never said the two rods were equal in sensitivity - i would re-read my post. i said i didn't think the difference in sensitivity justifies the massive price difference. and have you even fished with a BPS extreme rod to make that statement? Actually it's 15 months old. lol This is one of those threads that adds no value. Have a specific like or dislike about a certain rod, that may be worthy of discussion; a general condemnation of any brand, esp one that has stood the test of time like GLoomis is just trolling in my opinion. I don't own any Loomis rods-not because I think they they are over-priced, just outside of my budget. While I'm at it: I use inexpensive rods because I have determined what is "good enough" for me. I do not think my Extreme rods are comparable with GLX-they are not, and to say they they are is just silly IMO. To say they are not worth the price to YOU is valid, but it does not mean they are not worth the premium to others. Use what you like and can afford. Tell me why you like them. Anything beyond that has little, if any value, in my not so humble opinion. One more thing: you can condemn changes in warranty if you choose. I think the changes make good business sense. How that plays out will be determined by the market. I'm done now... quite the lovely bunch we have here on BR forums... no trolling here - just dropped ~400 on two used MBR GLX's and not particularly happy w/ the value per dollar I am getting currently compared to other rods i own/have used (in this case the BPS extreme) looking for some actual input and help on what i experienced w/ the rods and i wasn't talking about anything but comparing sensitivity - they are most certainly not equal rods - the extreme rods are very heavy and the GLX's aren't for example i'm just making a statement of my experience with a rod that costs more than 4x the price of a different rod i own and stating that it doesn't outperform it to the degree to make it worth it!
Recommended Posts