Shimano Curado 100D/200 vs Quantum Tour Edition PT1160

[Gov C Tyree]

First of all, new poster here.

Would like to add another baitcaster - possibly for cranks or other hard baits.  Considering etither a Curado or a Tour Edition.

Any preference among forum members for either of these two reels?

[TournyFish001]

welcom aboard- I have owned both those reels- they are extremely different from each other. Oh I just saw that you included the 200 on the curado.  Well the 100D is a lot smaller than the 200 and the PT1160, its(100D) great for smaller baits- although I still own it and love it for multiple applications great reel.  I cant speak for the curado 200, have held one in a store felt big so I went with the 100D my dad has the 200 High speed version and loves it.  Now for the PT1160, I gotta be honest and gave that reel many chances but I had an opportunity to sell it so I did without hessitation.  Here's why; the reel will NOT cast lite baits period- anything over 1/2oz and wind resistant it will handle flirt with a light spinner bait like I have and you will be very frustrated- I'm not saying it can't be done but it is sure a process to do so- In my opinion there are better reels for the money-  If you know you are only throwing heavy traps or pitching large plastics you may consider although there are better reels out there.

[roadwarrior]

Welcome aboard!

We have some Quantum fans, but not many. The brand has had

issues with dependabilty and quality control over the years. I'm a

Shimano fan, but many members are Daiwa, Abu Garcia and Pflueger

enthusiasts. There are a number of choices at your pricing point, but I

wouldn't be looking at Quantum.

8-)

[South FLA]

There are a number of choices at your pricing point, but I wouldn't be looking at Quantum. 8-)

Ditto

Welcome

[bass wrangler569]

I personally like Quantums. I have a Tour Edition and I love it. However, a lot of people on this forum don't like Quantums and I'm sure they have valid reasons. Personally, if I were in your shoes I would go with the Curado just because they have a better reputation for quality and durability than the Quantums do (I still like my Quantums though ).

[FishTank]

I purchased a Quantum Tour Edition when they first came out and I really liked this reel but I too had quality issues with this reel.  I ended up returning it.

At the price range you are looking at, I would recommend the Daiwa Zillion but if Curado and the T.E. are your only choices I would go with the Curado.