Shadcranker Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 The polls are closed, and CNN is ready to declare Shimano the winner in a landslide in the reel category. The polls just opened in the great rod debate of 2007. Let your voice be heard. Write in votes are welcomed. I'm sure I left some off, such as Browning, but I tried to list the higher end products that I own or would consider buying. My picks, in order: 1. Powell 2. Loomis 3. St. Croix Quote
Guest Texas_Bass_Pro Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 I have 1 Quantum but I favor Berkly Cherrywood. Have 3 of those. Quote
Super User cart7t Posted February 15, 2007 Super User Posted February 15, 2007 I've got around 5 or 6 Allstars and around 7 or 8 BPS Extremes and cranking sticks. I like both. I'll probably change my worm rods from the Extremes to Allstar Platinums next year or St Croix Avids. I do have a really nice Quantum Tour PT spinning rod that I really like also. There are lots of nice rods out there these days. I say find one and give it a try. As someone who buys and sells I get to try a lot of them out and they're all well made and very good when you're spending over say $100 for a rod. Quote
Super User FishTank Posted February 15, 2007 Super User Posted February 15, 2007 I picked G. Loomis but you might have added BPS's rods to your list. They too are quite popular. Quote
Super User Maxximus Redneckus Posted February 15, 2007 Super User Posted February 15, 2007 Shimano here out of them choices i like arrius also but how can u beat a rod with a lifetime warrenty for 40 bucks and with a great action (convergance) and step up 20 bucks (clarus) u get fuji reels seats and more choices in actions .If loomis sold there rods for half the price they wanted and added a over the counter warrenty from there dealer they might have a chance .BUT loomis is the BEST when it comes to tech specific rods wow they got like 150 diff choices... Quote
TournyFish001 Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 G-Loomis but I tell ya Kistler is very close- the Magnesium TS rod line is amazing and affordable. The GLX is still tops tho. I may get more value out of my Kistler Mag TS' great rods let me tell ya G-Loomis Kistler . . . . everything else Quote
Brad_Coovert Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 None of the above. But, if I had to pick from that list, I'd take Powell. Brad Quote
basspro48 Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 All Kistler, I love their Magnesium TS and Graphite Plus rods. I just hope I'll be able to afford a Helium LTA one day. Quote
Super User roadwarrior Posted February 15, 2007 Super User Posted February 15, 2007 My current line-up: 2 G. Loomis GLX 1 St. Croix Legend Elite 2 St. Croix Avid 1 Fenwick Techna AV 1 Lamiglas Going forward, I plan to purchase G.Loomis exclusively. Quote
Super User Alpster Posted February 15, 2007 Super User Posted February 15, 2007 My current line up 2 Loomis GLX 4 Loomis IMX 1 Loomis BounceBack 3 Lamiglas 2 St. Croix SCIII I am partial G-Loomis rods. Ronnie Quote
llPa1nll Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 I have tried the GLoomis and the Kistler very nice rods extremely light and sensitive and nice backbone. However these rods are pretty expensive and they were not on the list of choices I was aware of when I did the majority of my Rod buying. My rod arsenal consists mainly of Castaway Rods (22) and All-Star Rods (4) exclusively. Quote
Hawgin Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 I will stand firm as the lone voice for Fenwick, although I doubt I will replace my St. Croix spinning rod because I like the higher power of their mediums for that rod. Quote
bugman Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 I Picked St. Croix and fish with Triumph, Premier and Avid models. I have been looking at the Legend tour, Legend elite and G.Loomis IMX/GLX for when I want to step up in quality. One make that I'm interested in and was not on the list is Falcon. This may only be a lateral move from the Croix Avid though. Quote
Bud Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 still Loomis the same as it has been for several years Quote
timmyswetarded Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 for a younger fella on a budget i love the shimano compre. when i think of loomis, things get hazy and i ask myself if im dreaming : Quote
BucketmouthAngler13 Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 out of all the rods i have my Fenwick Venture is my faverite. Quote
Super User Alpster Posted February 16, 2007 Super User Posted February 16, 2007 Custom's That's what it's about! ;D Ronnie Quote
bassin_man Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 Overall I love Loomis rods. But at the current time I am running Loomis rod for when I need more sensitivity and Crucials for where I need a great rod but not as much sensitivity. Quote
Super User Long Mike Posted February 16, 2007 Super User Posted February 16, 2007 It's really very simple. Do as much research as you can, and then buy the very best rod THAT YOU CAN AFFORD With few exceptions, almost all rods in any person's price range will perform pretty much equally all across the board. For example, if you buy a $20 rod, you can pretty much expect that most every rod in your price range will be equal in their quality. As you move up in price, the quality and the sensitivity of the rod goes up, but your ability to catch bass does not increase at the same rate. Quote
KYbass1276 Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 I had to vote St Criox because thats what I have been using up till now. I just ordered a new Loomis IMX MBR 843c 7' mh and waiting to get it before I can say anything about Loomis rods. Hopefully I wont be dissapointed. I'm going tommorow to BPS to get a new reel for it. I'm thinking a Chronarch 100b should go nicely with it Quote
BillyBob Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 If Kistler Lta's were around when I started building my own rods, I wouldn't have bothered! Quote
Super User RoLo Posted February 16, 2007 Super User Posted February 16, 2007 In my experience, Daiwa, Shimano and St Croix all offer excellent blanks at a fair price. If you're in the market for something esoteric, you might be happier with a Kistler, Loomis or Megabass 8-) Roger Quote
Big T Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 I voted for Shimano. My Clarus even though it is only $60 dollar rod has taken a beating, I also have a St.Croix Triumph that I personally hate and a Bps Extreme Spinning rod. I just received a Key Largo spinning rod for Christmas that I plan on using for Inshore saltwater. I may try to get another one for heavier applications. I am looking at getting a 7ft. Casting rod. My ulimate choice in rods are Cape Fear rods, my wife has one that I won as door prize. For saltwater those are the best rods. I know they use to make a technical bass rod but I am not sure how well it was made. It is a shame that htey had to close the factory here in Wilmington where I live. > My rods serve a dual purpose as I tend to saltwater fish than Bass fish, however if I were going to strictly bass fish I would upgrade to a Shimano Compre or the Crucial series. ;D Big T Quote
cabela10 Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 None of the above. I pick Falcon Cara Reactions Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.