Crucial or Loomis Dropshot rod?

[bassin_man]

I was looking at the Crucial and Loomis dropshot rods.  I was going to get either the 7'2" Crucial or the 6'10"(Think thats what it was) Loomis.  I know that the Loomis might be a bit better but is it that much better to warrant the extra cost?

P.S. Does anyone know what blank Loomis uses in their dropshot model?  Thanks

[cbfishalot]

I looked at both of the rods this year when I bought a new drop shot  rod.  I ended up buying the  St. Croix Legend Tournament Drop Shot Rod (spinning).  It's 6'9" ML with a X-fast action you might want to take a look at that rod also.  They also make a casting drop shot rod.

[fourbizz]

The crucial is a sweet rod for sure. In the 100-200 dollar range, I've really been digging the Powell Max series, just picked up another yesterday. The 702.

[Shadcranker]

Depends what series Loomis you're looking at. I own the Crucial, and it's a fine rod for the $$ for sure. Hard to compare that blank to a high end Loomis blank though (apples and oranges- huge price difference too).

For $170 ish the Powell rod mentioned above is a sweet stick. I am a huge fan of their BC rods; don't have a Spinning rod from them yet.

If money is an issue, the Crucial is very nice. Slpit handle design, innovative DS weight hanger, very light.

[Maxximus Redneckus]

Shimano for 2 reasons its a light rod and the best warrenty you could ask for..

[bassin_man]

What I mainly want to know is will I not feel/miss fish on the Crucial that I would otherwise feel/catch on the loomis?

[fourbizz]

What I mainly want to know is will I not feel/miss fish on the Crucial that I would otherwise feel/catch on the loomis?

I think the difference will be negligible, but a difference none the less.

[Alpster]

G-Loomis makes their drop shot rod in the new "Blend" ?? and GLX. I don't know much about the blend except it is cheaper and Loomis doesn't make a bad rod. I just bought a new Gloomis Drop Shot DS820S in GLX. I just got it last week and haven't fished with it yet, but I can tell you it's sweeeet! $259 from fatfishfarmer on ebay. JMHO

Ronnie

[bassin_man]

Anymore input on this before I make my final decision?

[Lucky Craft Man]

I never used the G Loomis Drop Shot Rod, but I have the 7'2" Medium Power Shimano Crucial Drop Shot Rod and I couldn't imagine a better rod for drop shotting.  It is perfectly balanced right at the exposed blank in the foregrip and it works great for drop shotting for smallmouth in 30 ft. of water.  I don't think you can go wrong with the Shimano and with the extra money you save from not buying the G Loomis, you can buy a nice spinning reel to match with the rod.  

[Alpster]

Shimano for 2 reasons its a light rod and the best warrenty you could ask for..

I love Shimano products and I am a card carrying member of the Shimano posse, but I have to dissagree about the warranty. Shimano will not help you with a rod unless the rod is obviously defective and you are the original purchaser. The following is copied from their respective websites.

Shimano's deal....

Shimano Rod - Limited Lifetime Warranty

As used herein, Shimano will mean Shimano American Corporation with respect to United States warranty claims and Shimano Canada Ltd. / LTÉE with respect to Canadian warranty claims. Shimano and Shimano Canada Ltd. / LTÉE warrant to the original retail purchaser that this rod will be free from non-conformities in materials and workmanship. Shimano's sole obligation under this Limited Lifetime Warranty is to repair or replace, at Shimano's option, a non-conforming rod at no cost to the original retail purchaser other than the cost of packing, insuring, and shipping the rod to Shimano. This Limited Lifetime Warranty will be considered VOID if the rod is found to have been subjected to repairs not authorized by Shimano, or if it has been modified, neglected, improperly maintained, misused, abused, or the appearance of the product reveals damage by your failure to provide proper maintenance.

G-Loomis asks no questions they just replace the rod.....

G-Loomis Xpeditor Program Details

A broken rod will never keep you off the water again. With the G.Loomis Xpeditor Service you can get a brand new rod to replace a broken one, delivered to your doorstep in as little as two days. Even if you're on a trip away from home (anywhere in the U.S.). No questions asked, no waiting around for warranty claims, and it saves you the usual hassle and expense of packaging, insuring and shipping your broken rod. Plus, you avoid any and all fees for rod repair.

Ronnie

[Hot n Tot]

It just depends on what you want. If you just want a good rod for drop-shotting, get the Crucial and I'm sure it's a nice rod. But if you want the best, and don't mind paying for it get a GLX and you'll understand why so many guys spring for it.

[lubina]

I have the DSR822s, it is just perfect.