Heddon One Knocker Top Water ?

[ChrisD46]

I'm finally tempted to try the semi - famous Heddon One Knocker walking bait ... I'd like to know your thoughts on this top water lure , favorite colors - and when you choose the One Knocker versus the Super Spook or Zara Spook ?

[Mobasser]

I've got a bone colored one I've used for a while. I use it along with standard walking baits. I haven't noticed if it's better or worse than my regular spooks. Both work well

[Mike L]

5 minutes ago, Mobasser said:

I've got a bone colored one I've used for a while. I use it along with standard walking baits. I haven't noticed if it's better or worse than my regular spooks. Both work well

Agree

I bought a couple with different bottom colors just because, but keep going back to the regular size Spook. 
 

It may work better at different times, but in the conditions I look for to throw a top water stick bait the Spook almost always was the better choice. 

 

 

 

Mike

[Deleted account]

If all the sizes of spook came in silent, I'd fish that, one knocker next, and rattler last, won't make a difference most times, but when it does, it really does...

[J Francho]

I have a few. I honestly don't know when one is better than the other. They get bit. 

[NorthernBasser]

My favorite color today has been Bone and Pea Soup Green. 

 

[The Baron]

I’ve got a One Knocker in bone color, that’s been a good producer for me on both species.  I’ve actually never tried a silent spook - I’d think that would be just as good or better on a calm day and/or in very clear water.  But that’s just me guessing.

[GRiver]

I don’t have any top water Heddon’s , one knockers. To tell the truth, I didn’t know they made them.
I have some lipless cranks that are one knockers, really can’t tell the difference.