Curado 150 MGL vs Tatula SV

[McBass19]

Curado 150MGL vs Tatula SV for jerkbaits? I recently had a thread comparing the SLX DC vs the MGL 150 and for the most part people prefered the MGL over the DC as the DC was not worth the money. So I made the decision to not go with a DC reel but then I got to looking more and it seems the Tatula SV and MGL are pretty comparable reels. Specifically for jerkbaits, does anyone have experience with both reels and make a recomendation? 

[JohnFromLisbon]

Are you trying to start a rumble? ?

 

Have you considered the 70 size MGL instead?

[McBass19]

4 minutes ago, JohnFromLisbon said:

Are you trying to start a rumble? ?

 

Have you considered the 70 size MGL instead?

I'm really not trying to start anything LOL just hoping for some opinions to help with my decision.

 

I haven't considered the 70 size, what would the advantages be? When I look online the 150 is lighter, holds more line and is a bit less expensive than the 70. The 70 also only comes in 7.4:1 and 8.1:1, I know I'm a minority here but I prefer the 6.2:1 gear ratio for jerkbaits. Not that that's a deal breaker though.

 

[JohnFromLisbon]

The 150 is lighter, just by a hair. I have both and I use the 70 (71 in my case) on my jerkbait rod simply because it palms better with it. Also, with either 20# braid or 10# fluoro, spool size is definitely not an issue.

 

Also, even though the ratio is higher, the spool is slightly smaller, effectively bringing in less inches per crank (about 29 on the 71HG, 26 on the 150), so they're closer than they seem.

Edited March 28, 2022 by JohnFromLisbon

[McBass19]

31 minutes ago, JohnFromLisbon said:

The 150 is lighter, just by a hair. I have both and I use the 70 (71 in my case) on my jerkbait rod simply because it palms better with it. Also, with either 20# braid or 10# fluoro, spool size is definitely not an issue.

 

Also, even though the ratio is higher, the spool is slightly smaller, effectively bringing in less inches per crank (about 29 on the 71HG, 26 on the 150), so they're closer than they seem.

Good points, I will have to put both on my jerkbait rod and see which one feels better. I plan to do the same with the Tatula but unfortunately you can hold it but can't cast it before buying lol 

[PhishLI]

1 hour ago, McGinnis_Fishing16 said:

Tatula SV and MGL are pretty comparable reels

If you bought one or the other you'd be just fine. If you set the Tat up for max distance(lower brake settings) you'll have a small cushion when throwing lighter jerkbaits without a weight transfer system. Here the MGL will require a bit more user input, but no big deal. Other than that the differences aren't earth shattering.

[JohnFromLisbon]

Good call. Try them both, even though the 150 is lighter I ended up liking the 70 more on that particular rod. On my jig rod, even though they both felt right, I went with the 150 because the bigger spool made more of a difference with larger diameter line.

[LCG]

I don't think there is a wrong choice. Both companies make very good reels. I gravitate towards Shimano personally.

 

I have both the SLX MGL 70 (150 frame size, with 70 spool size) and the Curado MGL 70. The Curado MGL 70 just melts in my hand. The SLX is also a small frame reel, and I would imagine the Curado 150 MGL would be similar. Not a huge difference but still noticeable. 

 

Line capacity has not been an issue for me, but that was with 10lb big game (14lb ish line diameter and breaking strength). Bigger line may or may not require more capacity depending on your style. This year I have the SLX MGL loaded up with 6lb yo Zuri hybrid (10lb ish line diameter and breaking strength)

And the Curado MGL loaded up with 10lb yo Zuri hybrid (14lb ish diameter and strength).

 

I do prefer is the brake dial on the side of the reel as opposed to the bottom. The Curado 150 MGL also has the side plate attached if that matters to you. The Curado MGL 150 also offers three gear ratios. But that was well covered already. I will mention my 70's measure 28" ipt full and 18" empty. So if you cast half the spool worth of line, your at 23" ish.

[Blaine Donders]

This is a draw. Go with the brand you prefer. I prefer Daiwa, some prefer Shimano. 

[Tatulatard]

3 hours ago, McGinnis_Fishing16 said:

Curado 150MGL vs Tatula SV for jerkbaits? I recently had a thread comparing the SLX DC vs the MGL 150 and for the most part people prefered the MGL over the DC as the DC was not worth the money. So I made the decision to not go with a DC reel but then I got to looking more and it seems the Tatula SV and MGL are pretty comparable reels. Specifically for jerkbaits, does anyone have experience with both reels and make a recomendation? 

I would take the Shimano.  I like to make long casts with jerkbaits and SV spools aren't wining any distance competitions unless they are SV boost which the Tatula does not have.  Use the Tatula SV on a worm rod and skip senkos. 

[McBass19]

16 hours ago, Tatulatard said:

I would take the Shimano.  I like to make long casts with jerkbaits and SV spools aren't wining any distance competitions unless they are SV boost which the Tatula does not have.  Use the Tatula SV on a worm rod and skip senkos. 

I think I'l go with the MGL. I've always been more of a Shimano guy, althought I did recently buy a tatula 150 and tatula elite P/F to try out. I have not used an MGL spool yet but I'm excited to see how it performs. Thanks for all the input guys. 

[Mr. Bassin II]

Another personal preference for Daiwa.  Like others have said, this my preference and nothing else.  Can't wrong with either.

 

[JohnnyF]

The 70mgl feels perfect on my Dobyns 684cb. I’m sure my 150mgl would work too but that 70mgl/684cb combo is something special. I have the previous gen tat sv and it’s a great reel too but just a tad bulky. I’ve got it on my 7’ mxf zillion and it’s great on that rod. I’m sure you’d be happy either way

[Bluebasser86]

I actually use a Fuego SV for my main jerkbait rod. Great for casting jerkbaits in the wind but without having to deal with ice in the T-wing, which is awful. 

[Columbia Craw]

I have a bit of experience with the Tatula SV and would get the Elite for jerk baits.

[ErieCan]

On 3/29/2022 at 10:02 AM, McGinnis_Fishing16 said:

I think I'l go with the MGL. I've always been more of a Shimano guy, althought I did recently buy a tatula 150 and tatula elite P/F to try out. I have not used an MGL spool yet but I'm excited to see how it performs. Thanks for all the input guys. 

 

That 150 MGL is a nice reel. I tried one. I own the 70 MGL and like that as well. I own Daiwa SV103s and the Elite PF. The SV103 is about as fool proof a reel can be. You have to try pretty hard to get it to backlash. The Elite PF I haven't used yet (season not open here). 

 

One thing though, I love the Daiwas but I always noticed that the Shimanos feel more refined. Like, tighter tolerances. Durability they seem pretty equal. Diawas at the higher end are spot on with Shimanos IMO.  All about which breaking system and feel you like. 

[Tatulatard]

7 minutes ago, ErieCan said:

 

That 150 MGL is a nice reel. I tried one. I own the 70 MGL and like that as well. I own Daiwa SV103s and the Elite PF. The SV103 is about as fool proof a reel can be. You have to try pretty hard to get it to backlash. The Elite PF I haven't used yet (season not open here). 

 

One thing though, I love the Daiwas but I always noticed that the Shimanos feel more refined. Like, tighter tolerances. Durability they seem pretty equal. Diawas at the higher end are spot on with Shimanos IMO.  All about which breaking system and feel you like. 

 You talking about a Tatula or the Daiwa SV103?

[ErieCan]

6 minutes ago, Tatulatard said:

 You talking about a Tatula or the Daiwa SV103?

 

I have the Tatula SV103 TW reels. 

[newapti5]

I'll actually go with the Tatula SV reel. Don't get me wrong, Curado MGL 150 is a mighty reel for the jerkbait task, it is just with the price of it, you could get a Tatula SV and some custom light spool. This way, no matter the size and weight of jerkbaits, you're coverd.  

 

Here's some shameless promotion: If you're left handed, I actually have some reels for sale at the flea market right now, including a Tatula SV, as well as others. 

[McBass19]

3 hours ago, newapti5 said:

I'll actually go with the Tatula SV reel. Don't get me wrong, Curado MGL 150 is a mighty reel for the jerkbait task, it is just with the price of it, you could get a Tatula SV and some custom light spool. This way, no matter the size and weight of jerkbaits, you're coverd.  

 

Here's some shameless promotion: If you're left handed, I actually have some reels for sale at the flea market right now, including a Tatula SV, as well as others. 

I am left handed and that would be great but I’m in Canada so it will be pricey for shipping. Thanks though. Aren’t the Curado MGL and Tatula SV very similar prices? 

6 hours ago, ErieCan said:

 

That 150 MGL is a nice reel. I tried one. I own the 70 MGL and like that as well. I own Daiwa SV103s and the Elite PF. The SV103 is about as fool proof a reel can be. You have to try pretty hard to get it to backlash. The Elite PF I haven't used yet (season not open here). 

 

One thing though, I love the Daiwas but I always noticed that the Shimanos feel more refined. Like, tighter tolerances. Durability they seem pretty equal. Diawas at the higher end are spot on with Shimanos IMO.  All about which breaking system and feel you like. 

I just picked up an Elite PF but haven’t been able to use it yet either. I’m excited to try it out, seems like a great pitching reel. 

[newapti5]

59 minutes ago, McGinnis_Fishing16 said:

I am left handed and that would be great but I’m in Canada so it will be pricey for shipping. Thanks though. Aren’t the Curado MGL and Tatula SV very similar prices? 

 

Daiwa reels have discounts and deals all the time, especially if you go the JDM route. Shimano reels, on the other hand, would be a bargain if you can find 20% off.  

 

Also, the newest Tatula SV may be pricy as the new Curado MGL 150, but the older versions would be cheaper with same performance.  You can even purchase a regular Tatula CT or 100 with much cheaper price, and get a Ray's custom SV spool for ~$35. 

 

[McBass19]

33 minutes ago, newapti5 said:

 

Daiwa reels have discounts and deals all the time, especially if you go the JDM route. Shimano reels, on the other hand, won't be a bargain if you can find 20% off.  

 

Also, the newest Tatula SV may be pricy as the new Curado MGL 150, but the older versions would be cheaper with same performance.  You can even purchase a regular Tatula CT or 100 with much cheaper price, and get a Ray's custom SV spool for ~$35. 

 

I see what you’re saying now. Good to know. I’ll look into it, thanks.

[ErieCan]

1 hour ago, McGinnis_Fishing16 said:

I am left handed and that would be great but I’m in Canada so it will be pricey for shipping. Thanks though. Aren’t the Curado MGL and Tatula SV very similar prices? 

I just picked up an Elite PF but haven’t been able to use it yet either. I’m excited to try it out, seems like a great pitching reel. 

 

I'm in Canada as well. When I looked, the 150 MGL is a bit more than the Tatula SV103. $250 CAD for the SV and $280 for the MGL 150.  

 

I just ordered a Daiwa Alphas TW SV from Japan.  Not that you needed another option, but our dollar buys more JPY than it has in years. Lol