Need a new reel, $200 budget.

[akmac]

2 hours ago, newapti5 said:

 

Yeah, that shouldn't happen for a new reel out of the box, probably a lemon then. 

On the other hand, my new reels usually were in the best shape after at least one trip on the water as "break-in" period. Sometimes even several trips. 

After reading this I decided to monkey around with it a bit more.  Threw the handle forward and it just suddenly started spinning the way it should.  Not sure if they are connected, but the reverse slop improved a bit after.  Still not as good as I like, but is now acceptable.  Maybe it does just need broke in.  Think I'll give it a workout this weekend before sending it back.  

[akmac]

I have spent enough time with the reel to consider it good and broke in.  Have not had any more grindy type noises on the retrieve, I'm guessing the grease just needed worked into the gears.  

First off this reel is not just super light, but super comfortable.  It palms so well, a joy to fish all day.    The retrieve is super smooth, even under load, just feels rock solid.  No gummy or spongy feel at all.  It is a super smooth, quiet caster.  I got around the same distances casting square bills as I did with my Tatula CT Type R, but with more control and less effort.  The convenience of being able to adjust the braking system without removing the side-plate is great.  The drag is pretty darn smooth, such that I didn't even know it was giving line on a 5.22 lber until I felt the spool moving with my thumb.  The drag is also super strong, you can really clamp it down if needed.  Really the only complaint I have is the slight amount of back-slop on the anti-reverse.  It's not enough to affect hooksets or performance though (probably just me being too picky).  I have decided despite the flaw, I like it so well I am going to keep it and just send it in at the end of the season to be looked at.  I have it paired with a MHMF St. Croix Victory rod, and couldn't be happier with the feel, balance, and palmability.   

[Tatulatard]

I recommend the tatula elite.  If you don't want to spend $250 then get one for $180 like I did from that chinease amazon like site. 

 

Never mind you went with the lews TP which is also another good reel I hear.  That light weight ivcb like spool looks promising.  

 

[akmac]

12 hours ago, Tatulatard said:

I recommend the tatula elite.  If you don't want to spend $250 then get one for $180 like I did from that chinease amazon like site. 

 

Never mind you went with the lews TP which is also another good reel I hear.  That light weight ivcb like spool looks promising.  

 

Originally what I wanted but I was pegged at 200 bucks.  It will probably be my next purchase, have to get rid of some stuff first.

[Kelvin]

Daiwa tatula SV TW 2021 version.  Can finesse and bang.  I've used it in saltwater for snapper and snook as well as bass and peacocks.  Please of drag and casts really well.  I did upgrade bearings and supertuned the gears myself.