which reel would you buy?

[TriCityBassin']

I want a Shimano DC reel for myself (and mainly for my son to use).  I am looking at the SLX DC ($190) or a used 2011 Shimano Scorpion DC7 ($165).  Considering that Shimano had to cut cost somewhere on the SLX Models...I've used them and they are good.  I know the Scorpion is solid with great bearings, etc but its old and doesn't have the HGN body.  I guess part of me just doesn't want the SLX Model but can't afford a new Curado DC LOL.  What do you guys think.

[TriCityBassin']

HGN, Hagane is cold forged gears and frame that is super rigid and tight.  It's a feature on the better Shimano reels.  thanks for the insight, I had no idea those reels were bad.  That is prob why so many available.  Do you know the specific problems?

[Tywithay]

The DC on that Scorpion model was terribly overbraked and it didn't make the patented DC whine. Some people prefer that, but I like when it sings. They are not bad reels, but not great either. The IDC4 system is a pretty big improvement. The old Curado platform was one of the more comfortable palming reels they ever made and they're made to last. Basically, if you want better performance, go SLX, if you want better made, go Scorpion. If it were me, I'd look for a used Curado DC, if you're sold on a DC reel.

[jbsoonerfan]

I don't know your exact budget, but there is a pretty popular auction site where the Curado DC can be had for $200 or a few dollars more. In fact there is one right now that is $200 BIN with free shipping.

[Ogandrews]

I’d say try to find a curado DC on sale but if not I’d go with the slx, I’ve gotten burned too many times buying used reels I’m not a fan anymore.

[TriCityBassin']

7 hours ago, Tywithay said:

The DC on that Scorpion model was terribly overbraked and it didn't make the patented DC whine. Some people prefer that, but I like when it sings. They are not bad reels, but not great either. The IDC4 system is a pretty big improvement. The old Curado platform was one of the more comfortable palming reels they ever made and they're made to last. Basically, if you want better performance, go SLX, if you want better made, go Scorpion. If it were me, I'd look for a used Curado DC, if you're sold on a DC reel.

Agree on build.  Not concerned about the whine.  Used Curado DC are hard to find...probably says something about build quality.  I was trying to be cheaper, that $200 is the lowest I've seen on the Curado.  I found a pawn shop that had one for 175...but then they wanted 15 to ship it.  thanks for the input, I will keep looking and seeing if i can squeeze my budget.