Best Topwater Frog?!

[Thomas Olson]

Hello everyone,

I hope everyone’s days are going well. Ive been thinking a bit about restocking the frogs a bit and maybe try a few new ones. But I thought I would ask some other bass fisherman their opinions. So what do you guys think is the best topwater frog? I personally have tried spro and the booyah pad crashed the most. I like them both but the pad crashers price is better. Anybody got any suggestions for better frogs?

 

Thanks and happy fishing!!

Thomas

[Bluebasser86]

No reason to get away from the Pad Crasher. I personally prefer the popping Pad Crasher. If you want to try something a little different then you could pick up a Toadrunner and give one of those a shot if you have enough open water where you're fishing.  I've fished a lot of different kinds of frogs, but the 2 you listed are the best 2 I've fished, I just don't think there's enough benefits to the Spro to justify spending the extra money unless they have a color that just kills it for you. 

[jtharris3]

I throw a frog a lot! I have several from different brands. By far the Pad Crasher has produced more and bigger fish for me! 

[Heartland]

I have used the Jackall Iobee for many years.  One of the easiest frogs to walk, and needs no hook or leg tuning out of the box.  Tie it on and go to work.

 

[NittyGrittyBoy]

Spro vote from me. Black popping frog, black regular frog.

 

All you need.

[roadwarrior]

Not technically a frog, but the Rage Tail Toad has been killer for me.  The Toad can be rigged

totally weedless which comes in handy fishing in the grass and pads.

 

 

 

[the reel ess]

My $0.02: Just buy other colors and the smaller size of the Pad Crasher models. I've got some other brands and they aren't better. The PC stays tied on my frog combo.

[Boomstick]

I like the Live Targets the best, but they're expensive. So my frog collection consists of about 40% Live Targets, 40% Pad Crashers and then I have a Spro, a KVD and maybe another.

[J Francho]

Pad Crashers all day long.  For toads, I like the Yum Tip Toad and Ragetail Toad.

[kbeeb374]

Popping frog: Spro then Pad crasher (I am trying the jackall gavacho this year as well)

Walking frog: Pad crasher then spro then the 65 size live target

 

Basically you are set with pad crashers and spros..

[RubberDuck]

I also like the pad crasher.  It walks well, doesn't take on water, and the price is right.

[rod snapper]

Another vote for the pad crasher, its simply the best in its league.

[punch]

I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the Terminator Jr's yet. Those frogs are pretty phenomenal. This year i'm pretty much only throwing the Terminator Walking Frog Jr's and the Jackall Gavacho poppin frogs. 

[bhoff]

I've been using the Deps Slither K and Buster K for a while now and they have produced the best results for me. Both are extremely easy to walk and have a great set of hooks. Probably the only lure that I can justify spending $20 on. Not too concerned of breaking off when using 50lb braid pond fishing.

[Brett's_daddy]

I have a bunch of different kinds (Spro, Jackall, R2S, Terminator) I really like the Terminator Walking Frog...it is so easy to walk and if I can make it walk ANYBODY can !!!

[Junger]

The Spro popping bronzeye in rainforest black is my best producing frog, I basically just keep it tied on my frogging rod and don't use any other ones I have. I did get an Evergreen SoftShell in black that I'm going to try this year. It has a semi-cupped face, and a fur type tail.

[The Maestro]

Another vote for the Pad Crasher.  Not even taking price into consideration, it would still be the best imo.  Add in the fact that it's also one of the least expensive and it's an easy call.

[MAN]

14 hours ago, jtharris3 said:

I throw a frog a lot! I have several from different brands. By far the Pad Crasher has produced more and bigger fish for me! 

In your opinion why do you think it has produced bigger fish for you?  Thanks in advance

[umckibben]

Hard to argue with results, pad crasher, close 2nd for me would be R2S bully wa

[greentrout]

give me the old school snag proof frog ... never saw a reason to change ...

 

 

[Fishing_FF]

Scum frog. 

 

@Mike L turned me on to them. 

 

These frogs are soft, which allow the hooks to really stick the fish. The original series has Gammy (I believe it is a 3/0) frog hooks, but I prefer the stout and sharp Owner 4/0 frog hooks found on the Trophy Series line of Scum Frogs. Much cheap than some other brands I've tried, too. 

[Harold Scoggins]

Pad Crasher, Live Target, River2Sea, etc, they're all good. However, when I need to move some cabbage, only the King will do.

[LonnieP]

10 hours ago, Boomstick said:

I like the Live Targets the best, but they're expensive. So my frog collection consists of about 40% Live Targets, 40% Pad Crashers and then I have a Spro, a KVD and maybe another.

I prefer Live Targets as well. They don’t hang up in the pads as much as the Pad Crashers.

[NorthernBasser]

Frog fishing is probably my favorite way of fishing.

 

It's hard for me to pick just one brand. Booyah Pad Crasher is probably my favorite overall. But I LOVE the Scum Frog especially if I'm fishing real thick stuff. I like the Pro Series. Already comes with rattles inside.

 

Jackall Kaera is a smaller frog that works great. Live Target in the Green Brown color is money. Jackall Gavacho Frog is another one that does well for me. Easy to walk and spits water quite well. Use in more open water situations.

 

75% of the time I'm throwing black color. 

[SlappinKraken]

My favorite is snag proof Bobby's perfect frog. It's the only one I buy now, and I've tried most of the other popular frogs.