PB&J Sandwich

[Catt]

My granddaughter thinks I'm a little weird, don't answer that it aint the question.

 

Instead of spreading the peanut butter on the bread & then the jelly on top.

 

I mix the peanut butter & jelly in a small bowl & then spread it on the bread. Sometimes like right now I'll eat it on saltine crackers.

 

Oh yeah it has to be Smuckers Concord Grape Jelly!

 

Y'all ever try that!  ?

[MN Fisher]

I spread the peanut butter on one slice, the jelly on the other slice, then put them together.

 

Polanar All-Fruit seedless blackberry...nothing else compares.

[Todd2]

7 minutes ago, Catt said:

My granddaughter thinks I'm a little weird, don't answer that it aint the question.

 

Instead of spreading the peanut butter on the bread & then the jelly on top.

 

I mix the peanut butter & jelly in a small bowl & then spread it on the bread. Sometimes like right now I'll eat it on saltine crackers.

 

Oh yeah it has to be Smuckers Concord Grape Jelly!

 

Y'all ever try that!  ?

Yeah, she's right...that's weird.?

[EGbassing]

9 minutes ago, Todd2 said:

Yeah, she's right...that's weird.?

I have to agree with you. (haha sorry Catt ?)

[Choporoz]

I wouldn't go so far as to call it weird,  but it does seem like too much work.  One of the joyful aspects of pb&j is the simplicity and ease of construction.

[TOXIC]

You can buy PB&J premixed in the jar.  

 

I buy Uncrustables for the boat.   

[Joshua van Wyk]

59 minutes ago, Catt said:

My granddaughter thinks I'm a little weird, don't answer that it aint the question.

 

Instead of spreading the peanut butter on the bread & then the jelly on top.

 

I mix the peanut butter & jelly in a small bowl & then spread it on the bread. Sometimes like right now I'll eat it on saltine crackers.

 

Oh yeah it has to be Smuckers Concord Grape Jelly!

 

Y'all ever try that!  ?

I strongly dislike peanut butter and jelly sandwiches,  instead what I do is I mix peanut butter and Lyles golden syrup then put it on the bread. Try it!

[Jigfishn10]

1 hour ago, MN Fisher said:

I spread the peanut butter on one slice, the jelly on the other slice, then put them together.

Will say, that I do it this way only to save a vessel from having to be washed.

 

Although, peanut butter and banana is my choice.

[Tennessee Boy]

8 minutes ago, Jigfishn10 said:

Although, peanut butter and banana is my choice.

Yeah,  peanut butter, banana, and honey.   Elvis used to eat these fried in butter...  That’s what killed him.

[Jigfishn10]

1 minute ago, Tennessee Boy said:

Yeah,  peanut butter, banana, and honey.   Elvis used to eat these fried in butter...  That’s what killed him.

Are you sure it was just the sandwich that killed him?

[fishwizzard]

1 hour ago, MN Fisher said:

I spread the peanut butter on one slice, the jelly on the other slice, then put them together.

This is the only reasonable way to do it.  I do mostly skip the jelly and sub in a banana.  I also do this thing I call "mega-chunky" where I add a small handful of cocktail peanuts to the sandwich.  I accidentally bought creamy one day and wanted some crunch.  I ended up loving it and it's now the standard method.

 

The last hiking trip I took I was too lazy/cheap to figure out proper food, so I just brought along a jar of PB, a big bag of salted cocktail peanuts, and a package of good flour tortillas.  A bit monotonous, but very low-fuss.  

[Catt]

1 hour ago, Joshua van Wyk said:

I strongly dislike peanut butter and jelly sandwiches,  instead what I do is I mix peanut butter and Lyles golden syrup then put it on the bread. Try it!

 

 

[J Francho]

2 hours ago, MN Fisher said:

I spread the peanut butter on one slice, the jelly on the other slice, then put them together.

This is the correct way to make it.  I'm a Smuckers strawberry jam, or homemade freezer jam guy.

[NYWayfarer]

3 hours ago, MN Fisher said:

 

Polanar All-Fruit seedless blackberry...nothing else compares.

 

Would you please pass the jelly!!

 

Smuckers Goober and Grape is great. No mixing and you only have to use one knife and spread on both bread slices.

 

[A-Jay]

Rarely will I turm down a half melted in the sun Fluff-a- nutter

A-Jay 

[NHBull]

Peanut butter on both pieces of bread

jelly in the middle, so the jelly doesn’t soak through 

?

[Junger]

1 hour ago, NHBull said:

Peanut butter on both pieces of bread

jelly in the middle, so the jelly doesn’t soak through 

?

I one up your culinary PBJ masterpiece...

 

Two slices of bread, peanut butter on each one. Place each one aside, peanut butter facing up.

Take third slice of bread, jelly on both sides, then in between the other two slices with peanut butter.

 

Triple decker PBJ....the Big Mac of PBJ's!

[halochef]

I make the PB&J then grill it.   somtimes i add bacon.  sometime 3 slice of bread  PB on one. jelly on one butter on the 3rd.  and once in a while slice a banana w/ the PB&J.  and some times a Peanut butter cream pie!!

[Log Catcher]

I have to agree with @MN Fisher. Peanut Butter one one slice of bread and grape jelly on the other one. Peanut Butter is one the four major food groups as far as I'm concerned. Beef, Pizza, and dessert are the other three.

[Way north bass guy]

Pretty much any combo of pb and j is good with me, except our 9 year old is allergic to peanuts, so now it’s almond butter or sunbutter for me. Sometimes if we’re out without him, I’ll load up on the Kraft extra creamy pb, cause nothing compares to the real thing ?

[Bluebasser86]

PB&J is my boat lunch of choice. Added bonus if I have some Sun Chips to put in the middle of the sandwich. I prefer strawberry jelly, but my mom makes homemade blackberry jelly every year that is better than anything in the stores that I eat until it's gone. 

[jimmyjoe]

   Why did you hafta go do this? It's 11:56 and now you went and made me HUNGRY!     jj

[islandbass]

I love smuckers.  I love concord jelly. Who knew I’d be sandwiched between Catt and JF, lol. 

 

As as weird as you do it Catt, it is functional and does the job. 

 

The beauty of peanut butter is that it really doesn’t matter which sweet thing you pair it with...

jelly

honey

jam

bananas

syrup

 

 

this sandwich was a staple back in my snowboarding days. 

[Log Catcher]

22 hours ago, Catt said:

My granddaughter thinks I'm a little weird, don't answer that it aint the question.

 

Instead of spreading the peanut butter on the bread & then the jelly on top.

 

I mix the peanut butter & jelly in a small bowl & then spread it on the bread. Sometimes like right now I'll eat it on saltine crackers.

 

Oh yeah it has to be Smuckers Concord Grape Jelly!

 

Y'all ever try that!  ?

You are not weird. More than likely going senile. You haven't totally lost it if you still like pb&j sandwiches. It also has to be Jif peanut butter. 

[NHBull]

The question no one has answered and shocked it hasn't come up.

Creamy or chunks, and don't be an idiot and say Keto.....nobody like Keto peanut butter ?