Return or not?

[J Francho]

1 hour ago, CrankFate said:

Line slip is a myth from the days of shiny Kevlar line and smooth chrome or Bakelite spools.

I don't think so.  We see a new thread just about every week bringing up slippage.  Always starts with, "No matter how hard I tighten the star, my drag slips..."

[Boomstick]

On 3/17/2019 at 5:36 PM, jbsoonerfan said:

It is .008 diameter. Not sure how skilled you are with a baitcaster or what you will be tossing, but I'm not going to attempt to fish 15 lb braid on a baitcaster and I consider myself pretty skilled with one.

I have heard of people doing it, but I'm not going to try. Personally, I don't go below 40lbs with braid on a baitcaster (I might consider 20 or 30lb line on a deep cranking setup once I get a boat).

[CrankFate]

5 hours ago, J Francho said:

I don't think so.  We see a new thread just about every week bringing up slippage.  Always starts with, "No matter how hard I tighten the star, my drag slips..."

:::facepalm:::

 

User error. Improper technique. 

[J Francho]

13 hours ago, CrankFate said:

:::facepalm:::

 

User error. Improper technique. 

Agreed.  It's a pain, but we're here to help that person.

[bigone5500]

I don't remember if my spool is perforated or not. If it is then I'll tie it that way. Thanks. 

[CrankFate]

7 hours ago, bigone5500 said:

I don't remember if my spool is perforated or not. If it is then I'll tie it that way. Thanks. 

Have a look at this:

 

Myth Busting: The truth about line slipping on the spool.

Many mistakenly believe that Spectra® fishing line will slip on the spool unless you take draconian measures to prevent it. Experience has clearly shown that putting on several layers of mono, dacron or duct tape is totally unnecessary. This practice is not recommended to solve a problem that does not even exist. Braided line grips the spool much like tread on a tire grips the road better than a smooth one with an infinitely small contact area.

Before you start spooling a reel, pass the line around the arbor twice and form a good knot such as the Berkley Trilene knot. Cinch it tightly on one side of the spool leaving a long tag end to be laid across the arbor. Spool the first full layer of Spectra® onto the spool in a close side-by-side fashion under tension of 6-8 pounds over the tag end. If this is done, the line will not slip! No exceptions have been reported but try pulling on it at this point if you have any doubts. When convinced, you might tell a friend that it works.

Continue filling the spool under tension without any exaggerated crisscrossing. Tension about 1/2 the drag pressure expected may be appropriate when spooling heavy- duty line. Exaggerated crisscrossing creates open space in the spool which may invite the subsequent layer to dig in. In any case, crisscrossing is a one-time-event because you would not attempt exaggerated crisscrossing when fighting a fish because to do so would give the fish the opportunity to shake the hook. Actually, even if you think you are laying the line tightly under tension in a close side-by-side fashion, it is likely that you can’t see that you are crossing several wraps every turn because the line is so small diameter.

Some believe that Spectra® should be spooled on wet. This is not needed, but if it makes you happy, OK. The main concern with wet spooling is that often insufficient tension is applied. Fresh water causes no problems, but I would not use sea water which has about 3.5% salt (about 1/3 pound per gallon). Salt causes spool erosion. You would be saturating the line with salt all the way down to the bottom of the spool to start trouble later.

 

http://www.bhptackle.com/pages.php?pageid=36

[J Francho]

I’ll give it try on a smooth finesse spool that isn’t ported. Should be a good acid test. 

[CrankFate]

37 minutes ago, J Francho said:

I’ll give it try on a smooth finesse spool that isn’t ported. Should be a good acid test. 

It’ll work. Using a tag end across the spool, spooled tightly, braid never slips.