Would You Rather?

[smr_hga]

Edit: LiftedSquare13 failed horribly at making a poll so you'll have to view the question somewhere down there vvv

[EricTheAngler]

Whats the poll? 

[A-Jay]

Nope ~ No way I'd Never  . . . . .

 

Not even if you asked nicely.

 

And please don't ask again.

 

 

A-Jay

[smr_hga]

Whats the poll? 

I can't get it to show up! Never done a poll before. Well this is embarassing...

[EricTheAngler]

I can't get it to show up! Never done a poll before. Well this is embarassing...

What was it so we can still answer in text.

[smr_hga]

What was it so we can still answer in text.

It Was:

Would you rather catch a big fish that didn't fight much or a small fish that fought hard?

A: Big Fish, Small Fight

B: Small Fish, Big Fight

I Vote A

[EricTheAngler]

It Was:

Would you rather catch a big fish that didn't fight much or a small fish that fought hard?

A: Big Fish, Small Fight

B: Small Fish, Big Fight

I Vote A

Fish Fights are fun, but big fish are fun to. I have to pick big fish because my pb is small at this point.

[Jar11591]

A

[soflabasser]

I vote for catching a big fish over tiny fish.

[Big C]

A.

[Catch and Grease]

Big fish so I can take a picture and brag to my bros hahaha

[68camaro]

A.  I still haven't caught a really big one.

[Senko lover]

Notice the disparity in all the answers you're getting

[clh121787]

A. No brainer imo

[Derekbass02]

A of course. Unless I got paid for choosing B. LOL

[smr_hga]

Notice the disparity in all the answers you're getting

Haha i expected this. Part of me just wanted to ask to see if anyone would choose B.

[NorcalBassin]

A      

[slonezp]

All you guys voting A should become walleye fishermen.

 

I vote B. Mind you the OP used the word fish and not bass. A 2lb hybrid striper will put up 10X the fight a 2lb largemouth will. If we are strictly talking LMB than A would be the answer  

[scaleface]

If I dont vote do I lose the right to complain if I dont catch any bass ?

[Maxximus Redneckus]

For me its 20% fight 50% jumping 30% will she snag me or throw the lure.

[bholtzinger14]

I think if people preferred B you would see a lot of light and ultra light combos on the water. 

[smr_hga]

Mind you the OP used the word fish and not bass.

Yes any type of fish would count. Not just a LMB.

[soflabasser]

I agree that Hybrid Striper fight much harder for their size,but still rather catch another 10 pound bass than a 2 pounder!

[MIbassyaker]

All you guys voting A should become walleye fishermen.

 

I vote B. Mind you the OP used the word fish and not bass. A 2lb hybrid striper will put up 10X the fight a 2lb largemouth will. If we are strictly talking LMB than A would be the answer  

 

My wife's uncle -- a walleye fanatic -- tries to pick on me for targeting a species I don't eat....my counter is always, at least I target a species capable of resisting....

[Fishing Rhino]

The main reason I quit fishing when the weather turned cold was because it was not a fair fight. 

 

A few years ago I set a goal to catch a bass every month of the year from a pond which has very good largemouth fishing.  I caught three nice bass on Dec 31.  It wasn't really fun even though they were between four and five pounds.  They were like dragging in an old tire.  They'd try to jump and could barely get their noses out of the water.  It was not much better than dragging in dead weight.

 

I went out on January 1.  I got on the water and was not really looking forward to catching a January fish.  It was more out of determination to catch a bass in January than to have fun.  After about an hour, I realized that the goal of catching a fish in every month was rather meaningless when the fish were so lethargic.

 

I went home and packed it in until late March. 

 

Small or large, no fight equals no fun. Not for me anyway.