pbizzle Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 I completely HATE magnetic brakes. I really have a hard time casting with them, and I loose a lot of distance when I'm not backslashing. I also dislike the external knobs that they come with, because with the way that I palm my reels they tend to get adjusted on accident. The final and probably largest reason I dislike them is because I forget to adjust the magnets, but with the centrifugal brakes I can set them and forget them. This is why I only use reels with centrifugal brakes and avoid magnetic and dual braking reels. I was thinking about picking up either the pro qualifier or carbonlite while they're on sale, but they have a dual cast control system. I was just curious if it would be okay if I removed the magnets from the sideplate. Can this affect performance in any way (besides for the obvious)? Quote
BassResource.com Administrator Glenn Posted March 27, 2014 BassResource.com Administrator Posted March 27, 2014 Just turn the magnets off Beat me to it. Quote
Zeeso Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 On one of my pq reels the magnetic brake is broke. I took it out, I haven't used it yet, but I usually have them off or really low so I don't see how it would be a problem, ill report back when I use it. Quote
pbizzle Posted March 27, 2014 Author Posted March 27, 2014 I knew about turning them off, but my problem is hitting the knobs and turning them back on when I palm the reel. Then I don't realize that it's happened and it completely screws with me. That probably sounds like a stupid reason, but it's happened to me a lot. Maybe a knob like they use on the Daiwa reels where it's a lot smaller and not in the center would be better. The large dials that are used on most reels are another story though. Quote
BassResource.com Administrator Glenn Posted March 27, 2014 BassResource.com Administrator Posted March 27, 2014 Superglue. Quote
mjseverson24 Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 it does not effect performance to take them out other than limiting the reels casting versatility. 2 screws, give it a try if it works leave it, if not put them back in... Mitch 1 Quote
Super User gulfcaptain Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 I like the just turn them off idea. I've never even touched mine. I just set the thing to 0, adjust the tension knob, and off I go. Quote
Super User .RM. Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 The final and probably largest reason I dislike them is because I forget to adjust the magnets, but with the centrifugal brakes I can set them and forget them. This is why I only use reels with centrifugal brakes and avoid magnetic and dual braking reels. I was thinking about picking up either the pro qualifier or carbonlite while they're on sale, but they have a dual cast control system. I was just curious if it would be okay if I removed the magnets from the sideplate. Can this affect performance in any way (besides for the obvious)? I agree 100% with just turn them off. Quantums you bet it will in some way change the reel, and probably not for the best.... But those comments begs me to ask. Why if your only into centrifical brake reels would you pruchase a duel braking system reel and strip it down to less than it was designed for? Just asking... and before the smart arse's chime in because you can... Quote
bflp3 Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 I knew about turning them off, but my problem is hitting the knobs and turning them back on when I palm the reel. Then I don't realize that it's happened and it completely screws with me. That probably sounds like a stupid reason, but it's happened to me a lot. Maybe a knob like they use on the Daiwa reels where it's a lot smaller and not in the center would be better. The large dials that are used on most reels are another story though. PQ nob is recessed and has a clicker. I'd be impressed if you could accidentally turn it. Quote
Super User *Hootie Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 I agree 100% with just turn them off. Quantums you bet it will in some way change the reel, and probably not for the best.... But those comments begs me to ask. Why if your only into centrifical brake reels would you pruchase a duel braking system reel and strip it down to less than it was designed for? Just asking... and before the smart arse's chime in because you can... R.M. I guess it's just for the same reason we buy a new $20.00 crankbait and then change the hooks, or buy a new reel and swap perfectly good bearings for better ones, exchange a perfectly good handle for a different one. That's just the way we are...lol. Hootie 2 Quote
Super User Raul Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 Well, if you hate magnetic brakes why you purchase reels with magnetic brakes or dual braking system? .................... get Shimano, centrifugal brakes only. 2 Quote
Super User *Hootie Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 Well, if you hate magnetic brakes why you purchase reels with magnetic brakes or dual braking system? .................... get Shimano, centrifugal brakes only. The real answer, or should I say, the REEL answer. Hootie Quote
Super User gulfcaptain Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 I just learned to use my thumb. Seems to work most of the time, and when it malfunctions.....well then I'll look to swapping it out too.... Quote
Super User Raul Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 You guys are too funny ! Quote
NathanW Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 I also prefer centrifugal. But have a few Daiwa's I use that are magnetic. I have found that when dialing them in adjusting them more than 2 clicks at a time can cause major regrets. I start at 80% and work my way down 1 or 2 clicks at a time. Quote
John G Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 Well, if you hate magnetic brakes why you purchase reels with magnetic brakes or dual braking system? .................... get Shimano, centrifugal brakes only. X3 on buy Shimano's! Quote
Sherlock 60 Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 I knew about turning them off, but my problem is hitting the knobs and turning them back on when I palm the reel. Then I don't realize that it's happened and it completely screws with me. That probably sounds like a stupid reason, but it's happened to me a lot. Maybe a knob like they use on the Daiwa reels where it's a lot smaller and not in the center would be better. The large dials that are used on most reels are another story though. I have 5 PQ reels and there is no way that I could accidentally turn the magnetic brakes on. They are controlled by a dial and it takes some pressure to move that dia. There are no magnetic brake "knobs" that could move when you palm the reel. Same with my Daiwa Exceller. I am very confused... Quote
Sherlock 60 Posted March 27, 2014 Posted March 27, 2014 But those comments begs me to ask. Why if your only into centrifugal brake reels would you purchase a duel braking system reel and strip it down to less than it was designed for? Just asking... Been wondering the exact same thing. It took me a while, but once I learned how to use a dual braking system it has been a godsend on windy days and with light lures. 1 Quote
Super User .RM. Posted March 27, 2014 Super User Posted March 27, 2014 R.M. I guess it's just for the same reason we buy a new $20.00 crankbait and then change the hooks, or buy a new reel and swap perfectly good bearings for better ones, exchange a perfectly good handle for a different one. That's just the way we are...lol. Hootie Hootie, you purchase a 20.00 bait and change the hooks for the better.. Now how does buying a duel braking system reel, and removing one system make that reel better.. Quote
craww Posted March 28, 2014 Posted March 28, 2014 Another part of the problem Ive found is the on the BPS/Pure fishing type dual cast control reels, the individual systems dont often work well enough on their own. The optimum setting for max distance and usability utilizes at least a minute amount of both. Quote
Super User *Hootie Posted March 28, 2014 Super User Posted March 28, 2014 Hootie, you purchase a 20.00 bait and change the hooks for the better.. Now how does buying a duel braking system reel, and removing one system make that reel better.. I guess, just better for him, not you or I. I don't even change hooks anymore. Used to, but it got to where it seemed to me a major waste of time. I would never spend $50.00 on a handle for a reel that already had a perfectly good handle, but I can see why someone would, if that's what they wanted. Like Ricky Nelson sang, "you can't please eveyone, so you got to please yourself". Maybe he just really liked other features about the reel. Who knows, anyhow, that's all I got. Hootie 2 Quote
pbizzle Posted March 28, 2014 Author Posted March 28, 2014 Sorry I didn't get to reply to this earlier. Basically magnetic brakes have always been a problem for me, and I can do just fine with my thumb. So why not REMOVE THE PROBLEM and have a great reel that I can fish more efficiently. Hootie was right, it's really just improving it for me. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.