Which Seat Would You Buy???

[bolivier]

So I want to try one of these butt seats out with a tall pedestal but don't want to spend a ton of money in case I don't like it. So....which of these low cost seats would you chose??

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/ACTION-BOAT-SEAT-BUTT-SEAT-GREY-CHARCOAL-7501-503-/271263010180?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3f28890d84

 

or

 

http://www.basspro.com/Bass-Pro-Shops-Tourney-Special-Pro-Boat-Seats/product/10205166/

 

Thanks for the input guys!!

Brent

[slonezp]

You realize, those are only the seats without the post. I don't think it matters one way or the other. You will need to get the brand of the base and the diameter measurement to match up a post.

[war-eagle]

That's right.

The seats are inexpensive, the money is in the

Pedestal, and bracket.

[Fishing Rhino]

I think the height is more critical than the seat.  A good seat at the wrong height will be uncomfortable.   A mediocre seat at the correct height will be more comfortable. 

 

An adjustable pedestal is the way to go.  The proper height for you will vary with conditions.  A glassy calm day, almost any height will work, since your seat is a leaning post.  A sloppy, windy day in a rocking boat, and you might prefer a shorter post. 

 

Standing in one position becomes uncomfortable.  Slight changes in pedestal height can help prevent sore backs and legs.

[Fishes in trees]

What they said.  An adjustable post is preferable to one that isn't.  As far as the seat itself goes, get the one with the most padding.  Don't skimp.

[bolivier]

Yes I realize that is only the seat. I was just wondering which SEAT one would choose since they are basically the same price. I already have an adjustable post and seat plate picked out.  Do any of you have experience using the lean method? Is that how you normally fish?