If You Had to Choose One

[Texas10Man]

In clear water.

Watermelon Red or Green Pumpkin?

[bwell]

Green pumpkin all the way!

[Pez]

green pumpkin

[.dsaavedra.]

+1 green pumpkin

[Stasher1]

Green pumpkin all the way!

x2

If the water had a greenish tint I'd opt for the watermelon red.

[cbfishalot]

Green Pumpkin!!!!

[fmoore]

Green Pumpkin for sure. At least in my neck of the woods.

[ToledoEF]

watermelon seed

[InLikeFinz]

There are other colors besides green pumpkin?? Huh. 

[RoLo]

In clear water, I would not opt for the darkest color.

Roger

[Jake.]

clear to slightly stained: Watermelon

stained to muddy: Green Pumpkin

[aarogb]

Green pumpkin cause its more more natural than watermelon red.

[rat-l-trapper]

In clear water I'd pick watermelon red. If the waters really clear I'd pick an even lighter color though.

[jdw174]

Watermelon Red Flake has taken the lion's share of fish for me on Ky Lake this year....and last year as well. 

[midnighthrasher]

Green pumpkin

[Big Bait Fishing]

i picked watermelon red because i like a more translucent colored green in clear water , more natural to me ....

[Leever]

Green Pumpkin

[RoLo]

In clear water I'd pick watermelon red. If the waters are really clear, I'd pick an even lighter color

You betcha (Palinism).

In the crystal-clear phosphate pits of Florida,

the most popular colors are transparent silver, translucent white, translucent yellow & chartreuse.

Roger