NavyVet Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Looking for a quality mid-size spinning reel. Will be used for dropshotting and shakey heads primarily. Will also get used some for jig fishing walleyes on occasion. I have looked at the Shimano line and particularly Stradic C14 seris. Open to any and all suggestions and opinions. Quote
Flywatersmallie Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Assuming your budget is $200 going by the Ci4 you are considering, I'd say look at the Daiwa Ballistic. A lot of reel for the same price, comparable weight but a smoother reel as far as I can tell. If weight isn't a huge issue, the regular model Stradic is a better reel in my opinion. Or save some money and look at the Daiwa Lexa or Pflueger Supreme XT. Lots of good spinning reels under $200. Personally I'm not that impressed with the Ci4 though a lot of folks love them Quote
Super User roadwarrior Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 The CI4 would be an excellent choice. Quote
Super User 00 mod Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 The CI4 would be an excellent choice. x2! I love my Ci4 2500 Jeff Quote
thehooligan Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Id also recommend the ci4 or stradic fj. Im curious about the daiwa ballistic, i havent got a chance to handle one yet, but for the price it seems like a good choice. I like daiwa reels alot as well, especially my fuego 1000a... Also, the new okumas are coming out and are supposed to be alot of reel for the money.... Quote
Super User kickerfish1 Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 If you want a reel that is "feature packed" look at the stradic FJ. Personally you may find the 1000 size to be prefect if you are wanting to use 6-8 # line . Also I would say the 1000 size may also be a a better choice for walleye. The 2500 series will give you more line capacity and more lbs of drag. The main advantage of the 1000 series to me would be weight of the reel. The stradic CI4 is also a great reel and super lightweight. However it lacks "x-ship" and a few other features the FJ has. You can't go wrong with either... Quote
Global Moderator Bluebasser86 Posted January 21, 2013 Global Moderator Posted January 21, 2013 I just bought a CI4 last month and have really been impressed with it so far. Quote
Super User SirSnookalot Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 I've been fondling some as of late, not that an in store turning of the crank handle is going to tell you whether it's a winner or loser. That said I wouldn't want the ci4 for free, but the regular stradic is a superb reel. If I limited myself to Shimano I'd buy a symetre long before the c14. As far as my in store fondling goes, the quantum smoke is the most impressive I've seen, but can't say under fishing conditions how it will be. Any $100+ reel should be fine, I'd be paying attention to what feels best on my rod and if my eye likes it or not. Quote
Super User roadwarrior Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 Pretty harsh for someone who has only briefly handled an in-store demo. I have fished 00 Mod's reel a little and a CI4 I helped a friend buy in Alabama. Just playing with the reel below Wilson Dam I "accidentally" caught a small striper, +/- 12 lbs. I thought the reel performed as well as my Stella. I was (am) very impressed with the CI4. Quote
Super User J Francho Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 I have three CI4 reels. They are plenty smooth, lightweight, and strong enough to handle fish much larger than bass. Quote
Diggy Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 I've been fondling some as of late, not that an in store turning of the crank handle is going to tell you whether it's a winner or loser. That said I wouldn't want the ci4 for free, but the regular stradic is a superb reel. If I limited myself to Shimano I'd buy a symetre long before the c14. As far as my in store fondling goes, the quantum smoke is the most impressive I've seen, but can't say under fishing conditions how it will be. Any $100+ reel should be fine, I'd be paying attention to what feels best on my rod and if my eye likes it or not. If someone gives you one, Ill take it I know far too little about spinning reels to give advice on them, but Ill soak the advice up from others. Quote
rubba bubba Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Pretty harsh for someone who has only briefly handled an in-store demo. You mean like when Lgmouthgam fondled an in-store Lews and then proceeded to write a 5 paragraph "review" of the reel and how it couldn't be better than his Shimano? Oddly enough I didn't see the Posse slap him around for that buffoonery. 2 Quote
Flywatersmallie Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Well... I have fished a couple of Ci4's pretty extensively and I honestly felt there was something missing. I can't put my finger on what it was but one shouldn't feel that way with a $200 spinning reel. Lots of people are big fans of them and there is something to that, just not for me. I'll stick by my original statement that if I was going to pick up a Shimano reel, I'd save the few bucks and get one of the original Stradics. They are workhorse reels that just last forever. That said, almost all my spinning reels are Daiwa now and I'm very impressed with the new models out Quote
Super User J Francho Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 What's missing? Extra mass. Quote
Flywatersmallie Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 What's missing? Extra mass. I don't know what it is bud... It isn't the light weight. I own a Ballistic that weighs roughly the same and like it a lot. I don't like the round knob but that's a minor fix and wouldn't be a deal killer. I'm not sure what it is Quote
upnorthbassin Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 I think the supreme xt is a great reel for the money. You could even get the patriarch for under $200. The Stradic is a good choice too of course as is the regular Stradic fj. 1 Quote
Super User SirSnookalot Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 Pretty harsh for someone who has only briefly handled an in-store demo. I have fished 00 Mod's reel a little and a CI4 I helped a friend buy in Alabama. Just playing with the reel below Wilson Dam I "accidentally" caught a small striper, +/- 12 lbs. I thought the reel performed as well as my Stella. I was (am) very impressed with the CI4. More than once have I played with the ci4 reel and each time I was turned off. Just something about that reel just doesn't feel right, that isn't being harsh. Not only did the smoke feel much better but bubble wrapped $30 reels with the handle sticking out felt better too. Probably be no problem in landing that striper on one of those 30 or $40 reels. When ever I see something over rated or over priced I just think of what P.T. Barnum said. Diggy if I get a ci4 for free it's all yours..........I promise. 1 Quote
Super User roadwarrior Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 "Not only did the smoke feel much better but bubble wrapped $30 reels with the handle sticking out felt better too." Okay, that puts it in perspective and a smile on my face. That's pretty funny. Touche! Back to the OP, "some" guys really like the reel. You might, too. Quote
Super User Bankbeater Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 I got a Pflueger President 2 years ago and I love it. 2 Quote
Super User J Francho Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 I don't know what it is bud... It isn't the light weight. I own a Ballistic that weighs roughly the same and like it a lot. I don't like the round knob but that's a minor fix and wouldn't be a deal killer. I'm not sure what it is I don't like the knobs either, so I have Scott Hovanec make two sweet cork knobs: Quote
Super User MCS Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 Pflueger is the way to go, best reels for the money. Just picked up a President XT to got with my President 20 and Templar 35. Try to hunt an President XT down, they stopped making them in 2012 and I got mine for 44.99 that is half off for the 40 size. That thing is soooo smooth. If you can't find one of those there is the President, Purist, and Supreme that hit your 50, 80 and 100 price points and are worht every penny. Quote
Flywatersmallie Posted January 21, 2013 Posted January 21, 2013 Pflueger is the way to go, best reels for the money. Just picked up a President XT to got with my President 20 and Templar 35. Try to hunt an President XT down, they stopped making them in 2012 and I got mine for 44.99 that is half off for the 40 size. That thing is soooo smooth. If you can't find one of those there is the President, Purist, and Supreme that hit your 50, 80 and 100 price points and are worht every penny. The Purist is the new President XT. On paper, they are identical, price point is the same and in hand they feel the same. Same reel, different name/paint job. J Francho, those are good looking knobs! What's the price point on those? Quote
Super User MCS Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 The Purist is the new President XT. On paper, they are identical, price point is the same and in hand they feel the same. Same reel, different name/paint job. J Francho, those are good looking knobs! What's the price point on those? Yes, yes that is my point find an XT new in box now as they are discounted and it is basically the same as a purist but seen the XT as much as half off. But with the purist they shaved an once outta the weight 35 and 40 size reels if that matters. Plus they don't come with a spare spool this yr. I like spare spools one with mono and one with braid. Quote
Super User J Francho Posted January 21, 2013 Super User Posted January 21, 2013 I honestly don't remember. Scott is a member here, you could try to PM him, he's on daily. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.