Best Nfl Quarterback

[roadwarrior]

Let's face it, there are 32 teams and less than 10 guys that "belong" in the NFL. 22 teams have "filler" quarterbacks.

These are my BEST:

#1 Tom Brady

#2 Aron Rogers

#3 Drew Brees

#4 Eli Manning

#5 Peyton Manning

Who do you think counts?

[hooah212002]

1: Jay Cutler

2: Jay Cutler

3: Jay Cutler

4: Jay Cutler

5: a tie between Jay Cutler and Brandon Marshall

[tipptruck1]

I think your list is pretty good. I think the top three though are tuff. The top three in my books can be in any order. based in the last few years. I would have Rogers number one. Brees number two. Brady number three. I am not basing that on my support for the packers. Just what has happened in the last few years.

[Raider Nation Fisher]

1. Cam Newton

2. Drew Brees

3. Tom Brady

4. Carson Palmer (once he knocks the cobwebs off)

5. Eli manning

[Darren.]

Let's face it, there are 32 teams and less than 10 guys that "belong" in the NFL. 22 teams have "filler" quarterbacks.

These are my BEST:

#1 Tom Brady

#2 Aron Rogers

#3 Drew Brees

#4 Eli Manning

#5 Peyton Manning

Who do you think counts?

Hard to argue with that list, roadwarrior. As a Bills fan, and "hater" of the Pats, I 100% agree Brady is numero uno. However, I'm unconvinced of Rogers' pedigree. Can't put my finger on it, but I hear all the accolades thrown at him on ESPN, elsewhere, but I just don't see it myself. If Peyton has a phenomenal year, he's at #2, and I like Brees at 3.

Can't wait to see how Luck and RG3 do. RG3 was fairly sound against my Bills last week. Newton is an enigma...a phenom, but an enigma.

All IMHO...

[SirSnookalot]

For the most part a QB is going to be a good as his supporting cast.

Being from Michigan and a U of M alum.........it's Brady and it's hard for me not to like Matthew Stafford.

P. Manning is the closest thing to a "field general", one of the very few that could call his game. I see Manning and I see Johnny U. without the high tops, that said I think his best years are behind him.

[A-Jay]

I'm a Pats fan - but until Mr Brady beats the QB from the NY Giants (I can't even say his name) in the Final Game of the year - It's hard for me to to put the New England QB at the top of this list.

Really looking forward to this NFL Season ~

A-Jay

[Hyrule Bass]

Robert Griffin III, because i feel like being biased not because i actually believe it(yet) lol

[MCS]

I agree with Road Warriors list except number 5.

Peyton missed an entire season, might have issues throwing a deep ball for that I would say he is top ten but not top 5.

my number 5 is Phillip Rivers and 6 would be Cam Newton.....7 would be Joe Flacco(after he nabs a superbowl ring this year he will be top 5) then maybe Peyton Manning

[roadwarrior]

I'm a Pats fan - but until Mr Brady beats the QB from the NY Giants (I can't even say his name) in the Final Game of the year - It's hard for me to to put the New England QB at the top of this list.

Really looking forward to this NFL Season ~

A-Jay

Well, Mr. Brady has won a few rings for you.

Although I am one of his biggest fans, I still MUCH prefer looking at his wife!

[OHIO]

1. Cam Newton

2. Drew Brees

3. Tom Brady

4. Carson Palmer (once he knocks the cobwebs off)

5. Eli manning

How is Aaron Rodgers not on your list, but Cam Newton and Carson Palmer made it?

[5dollarsplash]

How is Aaron Rodgers not on your list, but Cam Newton and Carson Palmer made it?

What this guys said. Wisconsin bias aside I don't know how you'd rate Newton and Palmer above him.

Rodgers

Brees

Brady

E. Manning

Vick

[shootermcbob]

If we are talking Strictly about RIGHT NOW (not past history)...it has to be Aaron Rogers. Look at his stats last year and of course the 15-1 record.

If I had to win one game ...right now...Eli Manning.

My list goes like this

1) Rogers

1A) Eli Manning

3) Brees

4)Brady

5) Peyton...if he is healthy...if not

5A) Stafford

Really hard to watch Eli game after game after game just destroy my Cowboys. He reminds me...in the manner of late game comebacks,...of Joe Montana,

[Raider Nation Fisher]

How is Aaron Rodgers not on your list, but Cam Newton and Carson Palmer made it?

Because Cam is a beast. There is no denying that he is. After last year the Kid blew up. Think of what he's gonna do this year.

Carson Palmer. Im a Raiders fan. Just in case you hadn't noticed yet. Do you really think I would NOT list my teams qb? I mean come on now.

No Rodgers. I just don't care for him. I don't know why that is. It's just something about him that rubs me wrong.

[Captain Obvious]

If my boy Romo had 1 ring I'd put him on here but oh well

1. Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Peyton Manning - I would have him at #2 but with missing a year loses a spot

4. Being a cowboys fans I'm not going put a name here but he plays for those N.Y. Midgets

5. Rogers

6. Romo

[JoePhish]

If we are talking Strictly about RIGHT NOW (not past history)...it has to be Aaron Rogers. Look at his stats last year and of course the 15-1 record.

If I had to win one game ...right now...Eli Manning.

My list goes like this

1) Rogers

1A) Eli Manning

3) Brees

4)Brady

5) Peyton...if he is healthy...if not

5A) Stafford

Really hard to watch Eli game after game after game just destroy my Cowboys. He reminds me...in the manner of late game comebacks,...of Joe Montana,

I totally agree with this entire post except for the last part. It's very enjoyable to watch Eli destroy the Cowbabies.

[shootermcbob]

I totally agree with this entire post except for the last part. It's very enjoyable to watch Eli destroy the Cowbabies.

Hey....Come on now. That hurts

Seriously, Eli is just fantastic. I really think he is the most unbeatable "big game" QB in the league right now. When the chips are down...he is money.

[Jake P]

Robert Griffin III, because i feel like being biased not because i actually believe it(yet) lol

I knew something like this would come from your arse bro LOL!

[GLADES]

Brady

Brees

Rogers

[South FLA]

Brady

Brees

Rogers

Exactly, with Brady and Rogers significantly ahead of Brees

[Jake P]

As much as I hate to admit it, Eli has to be top 5. Not of all time obviously, but of right now. Not just for his superbowls, but what he did to get there. 15 4th quarter TD's is no joke. Reguardless if he is a mouth breather or has "dumbface", he is still a leader and pretty d**n good QB. Someone shoot me for hitting post please.

[JoePhish]

I'm not putting him on this list but I think Matt Ryan takes a big step forward this year, at least statistically...for you fantasy guys.

[guitarkid]

everybody knows this guy is obviously #1

-gk

[RyneB]

1. Brady

2. Breese

3. Rodgers

4.eli manning

5.Cutler

Peyton Manning is the best i have ever seen, but him missing all last year, he just cant make this list. I cant believe i seen Joe Flacco and Carson Palmer on this thread.

[llPa1nll]

Surprised not one vote for Big Ben Roethlisberger.

Brady

Rodgers

Eli

Brees

Rivers

Is my list, I hope the Pats can get back to the SB and meet up with some team other than the giants.