I posted a different thread about my experience trying out Wayne P's wacky rigging method. For whatever reason it just didn't work for me -- I'm certain the error is on my end. I would get a ton of bites but never hook the fish.
So I tried experimenting (as many of you have) with different ways to achieve the things I wanted to achieve in a wacky rig.
* Bait preservation -- I don't need a worm to last 10 years (like theBig1 from this old post), but I would like it to reliably last 1 fishing trip for me
* Minimal to zero hook penetration through the worm itself (again, for bait preservation)
* Hook oriented perpendicular to the worm (I know plenty of people stick'em just fine with the hook parallel)
* Weedless
* Easy to re-rig a new worm while fishing
--------
I found the Revenge Flipping Wacker jig and I love it. The lightest it comes in is 1/16oz, and I'd be eager to find a similar small jig with a fiber weedguard but 1/32 oz. Maybe something like this but with better/more reliable components. In any case, the Revenge jig takes care of my weedless concern, and I've pitched it into lily pads with no problems at all. I don't have any really gnarly timber to test it out on.
--------
Here is creation #1 and completed product.
Appropriately sized o-ring with a small size 2-3 split ring to create the perpendicular orientation. Something has to be done to prevent the hook from pulling back out through the o-ring, so I just used a hole puncher and punched out a bunch of circular plastic discs from that I then threaded onto the hook. It works well and has great hookup ratio. If your worm tears or a fish steals it, it's quick and easy to thread another worm right through the o-ring.
Some things I don't like about this setup:
- the o-ring needs to be tight enough or the worm will get pulled out
- problem is, the tighter the o-ring, the sooner the worm begins to tear in the middle
- getting the plastic circular discs on and off the barbed end of the hook can be a little fussy
-----------
Here is creation #2 and completed product and another completed product.
Find appropriately sized vinyl tubing. I ended up with 5/16" ID for 4" yum dingers, and 1/4" ID for trick worms and havoc money makers. I'm guessing I will need 3/8" ID for 5" yum dingers and swimming dingers as they don't fit with 5/16" ID.
I cut about 1/2" length of the vinyl tubing. The thread I linked earlier recommends a 3/4" length but that seems a little long for a 4" worm. I may go a little longer with a 5" worm.
I use a drill with 1/8" drill bit and drill two holes about 5mm apart. Then just thread vinyl tubing over your worm of choice, and thread a wacky hook of your choice in and back out of those 2 holes. With the holes 5mm apart, there is minimal (if any) piercing of the plastic with your hook. The 1/8" drill bit makes a hole big enough for the hook point + barb to pass through, but still too small for the hook/barb to easily back out through the hole. I tried pre-rigging the hook through the holes in the vinyl tubing, and then putting the vinyl tubing over a worm, but it was hard to get the vinyl tubing over the worm this way.
This looks much less prone to fish pulling the worm on one end and stealing it. It also looks much more resistant to a worm tearing in the middle, and even if it does start to tear, it's quick and easy to detect, allowing you to remove the worm and mend-it up.
Short of breaking off, the vinyl tubing should be easily re-usable and I don't imagine much (if any) breaking down of the tubing. Not within any reasonable amount of time anyways.
The final product looks pretty sweet to me but I haven't had a chance to try it out yet. To be determined how well it works, but I'm pretty optimistic about it.
----------
After creating the vinyl tubing version, I found a retail product online that is pretty much this exact idea. I can't remember the name or site. But regardless, it's certainly cheaper and pretty easy to buy the vinyl tubing (10 feet for ~ $3, and you're only cutting 1/2-3/4" at a time) and drill the holes yourself.