Don't know much about Erie, but, I fish Ontario alot. Cruise the shoreline looking for rocky shores. If you find rocks, you usually find the smallies.
I start shallow and work my way out to find a school. If you find a good school, you will get tired of fishing because they will wear you out.
I like to use 5 in. kalin's smoke salt and pepper grubs on a 1/4 oz jighead, just off the bottom. Not uncommon to boat me 100 a day!
ontario is 3 1/2 hours from me in NE PA you ought to try there.
If you need a guide, I'd be happy to go along, as none of my friends will go anymore :'(