Goose52, take it back if your not happy with it, I bet you will be happy with the UA Cold Gear "Fleece" glove. But cost 5 bucks more but worth every penny! The glove you have now does not have fleece on whole back hand but index finger am I correct? If so the "fleece" glove covers back hand/ per fingers expect the palm which it will be the same that you tried. Btw I took the golf gloves back because it got wet easily on leather palm. Too much hassle to put latex gloves on so I went with the Fleece UA. Doesnt hurt to try any or take it back til whichever suit you.