The method that seems to be the most successful on the lake I fish is run and gunning offshore brushpiles from post spawn to fall. Some days a spinnerbait is the deal, sometimes a crank, sometimes a fluke, topwater, etc. If I'm bouncing around and not getting bit on one or two lures, are you saying it doesn't matter much what I'm showing them so long as I show up at the right time? Do you find active fish and then start playing with presentation to maximize?
I know there are some people around here that have so much confidence in a fluke that they'll pull up and make maximum two casts to a brushpile with a fluke and if it doesn't get bit, they leave. And they'll do that all day. I'm just trying to avoid running around everywhere with a fluke or whatever and not getting bit for however many stops when those fish would have eaten a crank. But I also don't want to sit there and throw 5 or 6 different things if the fish have become suspicious after the first 1 or 2 things they didn't eat.
I guess what I'm trying to understand is should I be thinking of all the fish in the lake the same, like if this group is eating topwater, all the fish in the lake are. And if they're not eating topwater, none of them are? Or should I be treating each new location/group of fish as a "fresh start" where I play the game and figure them out? From observation it seems like if I can get bit a couple times on a lure, the probability of that presentation working elsewhere is high. But I also don't want to dismiss fish as inactive if they don't eat it, because I don't want to miss shots I didn't take. I hope that makes sense. Maybe overthinking it.