For me, it seems to run in cycles. One year they prefer feathered and one year not. Topwater is ALL I use because of the vegetation where I fish. With all the topwater choices (and I have and have used most?) the Super Spook Jr. has probably caught the most for me. Except for maybe an X-Pod jr. And you will catch fish almost the size of your bait, but also some big ones. Doesn't matter what time of day, or what time of year, they've always been killers for me.
Oh yeah - and you can't beat the fun of using a topwater?