The question seems to be geared toward quantity of fish.. I’ve found with big numbers quality happens too…last season went like this
chatterbaits, full size and flashback minis… flashback mini caught more, I caught 2 MA trophies on full-size and 2 on the mini. Countless fish just shy of trophy class.
booyah pond magic.. big numbers every year, 2 trophies last season.. 1 just shy.. same fish hit my next lure 5 days earlier. Catch and release works and I have photographic evidence.
Lunkerhunt Compact Frog (smaller of the 2 sizes).. lots of fish, 1 trophy class… 1 just under, same one that hit the Booyah 5 days later
4 inch Yum Dinger, weightless, texposed on an EWG.. lots of fish every year.. a couple just short of trophy class last season.
Small squarebills… I think they’re the 6th sense crush 25… 1/4 oz if I recall.. lot of fish.. nothing memorable size wise.
runner up is a ned rig, I had less success with it this past season but in the past it’s been my #1 producer by a wide margin.
The pattern in these baits is they are almost all small… small catches numbers here and with enough numbers size is usually mixed in..
For reference a MA trophy fish is 21 inches or more. Catch and release.
PB on the pond magic