I catch them down here on them on windy days or stained colored water. Like Darth mentioned I also catch the same on a SV-3 spinner bait in the same pattern. The best color for me has been the golden shiner in the 1/2 ounce. I lost a lot of fish initially with using trailers that are too stiff and slid down the hook when I hooked up. i went with the Z man and super glue and i am about 100 % on landed fish.
I will try the spunk shad as I heard from others it works well and I just cant help myself.
I have the new version and have caught a lot of fish in pads when I can reel fast enough to keep it moving high in the water, I wish they had it in 1/2 ounce due to our shallow water. That size outproduces 10 to one so far.
I initially only bought one and then seeing how it worked in pencil grass tried for a year to buy more, I broke off on stems a few times and was able to find it and braid floats so It lasted me until the hook finally broke off.
I just ordered a couple from BA Custom and will try them, they look like the blade is larger and might be easier to fish slower high in the water.
I never threw a chatter bait, always threw spinner baits and never had a issue,this weekend in a derby I caught 10 fish behind people and 5 were on that bait, 5 others while dead sticking a swamp lord frog. Maybe its just new and they havent seen them as much like I have never seen a guy let a frog just sit in slop or under trees.