For me, I have had better luck in clear MI water with swimbaits with subtle tail action. I LOVE the look of the Fat Impacts, but subtle has always done better. My mind tells me the Fat Impacts should work best but my result tell my subtle works better. For me this has held for summer and fall (down to 50 degree water, give or take a couple degrees). BUT, I do not have near the experience of AJ. I am still waiting for an invite to join him up north sometime I pour my own lures, but have molds like the Fat Impact and ones more subtle than the Hazedong shad (and Hazedong and spark shad knock off that I have not had as much time with yet, 2024 goals).