No it's a right hand retrieve. I cast with my right and retrieve with my right, I pitch with my left though. I also thought this could be the issue, but it does not happen with any other reel.
I guess I can try to replace the two washers in the cap and the o ring. Plumbers tape could work, but I would prefer to have it work with stock parts. I have ten reels so I don't really need this to work, but not being able to fix something bugs me to no end. I also really like this reel even compared to my 20 metanium. Thanks to for all the suggestions.