It’s a war zone down here in South Florida. Shiner anglers against the artificial guys, one way or the other, folks are up in arms. Headwaters Lake is the focus. A little backstory about the lake: Headwaters Lake is in Fellsmere Florida. In August 2020, after many years, it finally opened for motor boat use. It’s a manmade 10k acre impoundment located in Fellsmere Florida adjacent to the famed Stick Marsh. It’s managed by the St John’s River Water Management District and by the FWC. It’s catch and release only for largemouth bass and circle hooks only if using live bait for largemouth bass. Headwaters Lake is unique, not just any old impoundment. By design, it was to be a premiere trophy bass fishery. Biologist created and sculpted a terrine of islands, rock pits, staggered ledges. The heavy machinery work that went into excavating that place is utterly amazing. Some of the machine operators even carved big letters and words into the earth. Then the area was flooded and stocked with over 1 million largemouth bass. In short, it blossomed into one of the premier bass fishing destinations in the entire world. That’s right, fishing is THAT GOOD, with one of the highest percentages of a double digit fish daily….most all of which are caught on wild shiners.
This is where things get rather touchy. Because of the outstanding bass fishing, the charter captains took up the reigns in a real hurry, and rightly so. It’s not uncommon for a chartered boat to get 50 or more bass daily, with a lot of them 5 pounds all the way upwards to 10lbs or even more. Customers have a guarantee of many fish and a very high percentage of getting a trophy fish, or the biggest fish of their lifetime. The charter business is literally on fire, with big names and the likes taking advantage of the situation. People are booking trips like crazy. The word is out, trips are booked months in advance. A modern day gold rush! The scene at the small, dusty boat ramp is comical with threats, fights ... yet on social media pure rage and jealously … for all those who fish with shiners!
Many fear the lake is doomed, plain and simple, by the very act of netting and fishing with wild shiners. With white PVC pipe marker poles sticking out all over the entire lake, side by side, the netters have staked their claim. Doug Hannon predicted and warned against this in an article he wrote years ago. He warned about the depletion of the shiner population in the same area. He stated that the process of netting wild shiners kills hundreds of smaller fish just to get a few “good ones” for a charter trip.
Then there is the legality of netting shiners in Headwaters Lake. Some see it as commercial while others see it as their right or their privilege. The FWC says no netting if selling the wild shiners commercially. Some charter captains just say, “I’m not selling them, I’m giving them away to my clients for free.” A loophole? Maybe. Regardless, the only thing I can say is folks are very ticked off. Rage. Anger. Hostility. The fights over this on social media are downright brutal.
These arguments go a few ways.
First, is the idea that real fishing implies outsmarting a fish with a fake bait -- only in this regard is fishing considered real. On the flipside of that, the shiner guys say fishing is fishing, whether with live bait or dead bait or fake bait, doesn’t make a darn bit of difference, “and no one can tell me how to fish or what to fish with!” Another group sees shiner fishing as a means to destroy the fishing by fake baits, meaning that the bass are becoming “conditioned” to eat easily wild shiners thus avoiding their fake baits and diminishing the angler’s chances of ever catching a trophy. Another group views shiner netting as slowly depleting the natural food source of the bass fishery, thus wiping out the trophy fishery altogether…..and so the stories go.
I, myself, cannot make much sense of it. The hostility is so darn intense and so very hard to see into any argument or disagreement to make any clear meaning. Thus my reason to put this piece out there.
So, what are some of your thoughts on the matter? Have any of you ever experienced anything similar to this in your area? If so, what are some of the outcomes or solutions?