Paul, at some point, you may want to establish standards for yourself because, all too soon, space in your collection is the coveted item. Mine was never buy an item others would not line up to buy from me, with a couple other caveats. Then your time and labor is also rewarded -
- here's that 1918 Douglas patent freespool + anti-reverse - winding backwards, the yoke lifts the pinion gear from both the spool and main gear - note there's a clutch in the main shaft collar
and the delicate casting-brake spring, which this reel has in place of a clicker
You've definitely done the right thing making contacts on ORCA, and already reaped some benefits, both knowledge base and gracious gestures (at least partly driven by making space). Neither your nor I probably have a goal of winning a display medal at a national meet, but all of those guys have long passed an acumen of buying and selling well.
For those who may want to know the kind of things to look for, probably the best example I can throw up is the Pflueger Summit. My '51 Ward's catalog that Paul quoted on this page shows the postwar version, model 1993L, and you see a lot of those out there sold as "engraved Pflueger"
Here's the one you can potentially make a profit - this is the prewar version, c. 1928. Rather than nickel-plated brass, it's nickel-silver, has all the patent marks, and is engraved - note the details on the end plates. It's also the amber handle knobs that give it away.
Eric, the place you might want to begin is NFLCC
https://nflcc.org/upcoming-shows/
ORCA is kind of a spin-off of the larger organization, and with a membership overlap that makes them almost a subset of NFLCC.
For the fly reels, you'll find more history and interest on fiberglassflyrodders and classicflyrodforum.