A-Jay,
I just returned from a 6 week trip to a local res (about 40 miles in length), which has a good Pike population. In NW Montana, the damned things are everywhere now. I have no idea how many thousands of casts I made, and produced only one fish, barely into the decent range. I did catch 4 "hammer handles" as well. Spoons, spinners, plugs (large and small), plastics,, fly's (large streamer's) and rubber frogs. And several dozen smelt, from 4" to 8". I fished early (5am) to late, sometimes throwing bait and plugs until midnight. I made some big wooden floating plugs this past winter, 5" to 8" monsters, and would troll, or cast early and late. I also fished spin gear, baitcasters, and fly rods. There are widespread shallows (to 10 or 15") with mud bottom, and lots of milfoil. I eventually came home when it hit 100 degrees, and stayed there. Which is bizarre in Montana.
Starting in mid- May, the weather slowly warmed, and the snowmelt was raging, until mid June, when the water warmed substantially. I know there are good fish there, but cannot figure a strategy for getting into them. I have caught a few good Pike over the years, but have no consistency with the bigger fish. I am planning another month or longer back there this fall, so appreciate any advice.