Sorry I didn't post my set up or how I was setting the hook. Set up is a 7'6" MH Ethos with a 7.1:1 Menace 30lb braid to 15lb fluoro leader. Baits used were super hog, lizard, worm, etc. Hook set was sweeping to the side. I have seen numerous videos and read articles about fishing the rig, but my lack of connection really had me wondering. The only thing I can think of that I was doing different was my partner was using some sort of scent. Maybe that was all the difference in the world.
I asked him about the tap tap bites and thought they were blue gills, he promptly told me they were bass and to set the hook on anything I felt. He brought back in a lot of half eaten baits through out the day, but he also caught fish all day long.