Rather than start a new thread...
I found an antique store with a bunch of old lures. Some were behind glass and priced as collector's items, which means they're not for me. But some were just a buck or two, and these were the ones that interested me. I have a hunch that with the increased fishing pressure, throwing baits these fish haven't seen has to be some sort of advantage, right?
First up were some Rapala Fat Raps. I guess they make these again, but I haven't seen one in a store in decades, so when I found these at an antique store, I bought them out. Great for slow cranking. I consider these to be a finesse crankbait. Kind of like a Shad Rap, only a little different look. These were some of my favorite lures as a kid, and I'm glad to finally own some again.
Next, I bought a bunch of Heddon River Runts, Midget Digits, and whatever other names they sold this profile under. I'd seen these in tackleboxes of every adult as a kid, but no one threw anymore them by the time I was learning to fish, so I was familiar with them, but didn't know anything about them. I was surprised to find they don't float. So I guess they're kind of a cross between a lipless and squarebill? Anyway, while timing the countdown, I discovered that they have a really nice motion on the fall. So I figured these would be excellent for jigging for suspended fish or fishing bait balls. I haven't had any luck with one yet, but they definitely fill a niche that nothing else I own really does. And once the baitfish start balling up and heading into the shallows (should be soon now), I bet these will kill!
Lastly, I bought a bunch of Heddon Hellbenders. I guess they're making these again, or never stopped making them, but I don't think I've ever seen one in a store in all my life. I've seen plenty in tackle boxes though. But again, no one uses them anymore. So after some experimentation, I found out they don't cast very well for their size. That's probably why I don't see people using them. But they do pull cleanly through just about anything! Rocks, weeds, submerged timber, it doesn't seem to matter with these. So I started trolling with them, and sure enough, they catch fish! I dragged them through the nastiest stuff I could find (because at $2 a piece, I figure why not), and never lost one! I was really impressed by these. Being a kayak angler, I spend a lot of time slowly moving from spot to spot, so trolling is a way to make use of wasted time. I'm gonna get a lot of use out of these.