I bought an SS Air when they first came out, and I really enjoy using it. I actually like it enough that I recently bought a second one. The reel is super smooth and light with a super controlled braking system. As far as how it compares to the Aldebaran I would say they are about equal in smoothness. The Aldebaran is definitely more finicky to get dialed in, but isn’t too bad to adjust once you get it dialed in. I will say though that my least favorite part of the Aldebaran is the brake adjustment dial. It’s very stiff, and the numbers are very hard to read. I have perfect vision and I still have an issue seeing them half the time. In my use I would say that the main difference between the two is in the casting. The SS Air is a much more controlled and forgiving braking system, and the Aldebaran offers slightly more casting distance. I really enjoy both reels, but if I had to choose just one I think my pick would be the SS Air.