That is an interesting question. I've used this same guide 3-4 times before and each time it was wide open. It was only tough on our most recent trip. Last year we went out to a lake and caught 89 fish in 8 hours. The guide only fished with us for about an hour because I asked him to. On that trip and ones prior, I wouldn't say I was really learning anything from the guide. He is super laid back guy whose main priority is to put us onto some fish and also position the boat in such a way that makes it easy for my son and I to fish comfortably. Essentially this guide is like fishing with a buddy who owns a boat. I've spoken to a few guides and they would not let us use baitcasters, which I prefer. Anyhow, when we use different types of baits I normally ask the guide which technique works and go from there. I still have a hard time working a jerk bait correctly tho. After jerking for more than 30 minutes, my back and arm muscles get super sore.
I may opt for a different guide down the line who we can really reach us. Seems like anyone can catch when its wide open but when its tough out, experience obviously comes in handy to maximize time on the water.