I have seen and caught meanmouth or mulies, I don't believe that's what this fish is. For one there are no documented catches of spotted bass in lake pardee, it is known for brute smallmouth, suprising largemouth and then the trout, kokes and some amazing brown trout from time to time. The size of smallbouth in pardee is well known to some who fish there, personally my largest there is 3.75 lbs a respectable fish, but not a trophy, smallmouth come out of there every year in the 8lb range, so really the only thing we can go on are the markings and while they're not typical, they really aren't that atypical either. The largest meanmouth I've hear is 4lbs or so. So just maybe in the absence of spotted bass what we're looking at is one fat smallie caught by two different individuals a short time apart.