I think this is where @Scott F was going as well, with my not wanting to spend money on wire cutters. I guess I'm just oblivious to why you need them. When would you want to cut the hook instead of just removing it with pliers?
How would I kill the fish by catching it? I guess I just don't really understand this part. I get how fighting a giant 50 incher for such a long time that he's completely exhausted, then holding him out of the water for some minutes would kill it. But what about catching a 30 incher, unhooking it, and releasing it? I'm not trying to say I wouldn't kill a fish, or to deny anything you said, just trying to learn.
I do have a net, it can at least help with landing a bigger one whose whole body wouldn't fit inside. A 35 incher I could fit most of his body in the net, then have his tail hanging out, at least until I get a grip on him. That way I'm not dragging him anywhere on land.
What do you two think? Should I just get a smaller musky spinner to use? I'm not worried about getting them to eat, since they've never seen lures before, and 3 of them ate my brother's TUBE he was throwing. If they ate a tube, I'm sure they'll eat something actually made for them.
Thanks everyone for replying, I appreciate all the help and advice.