Wow, very similar story for me. I was actually born in Bradford, Pa and grew up near Titusville Pa - we had great fishing opportunities! I left the area because the family business closed shop when my great uncle died and the family sold it off.
Now I live just north of you in Albrightsville (20 minutes from Beltzville) and the fishing on this whole side of the state sucks. The people that fish around here keep everything they catch regardless of the regulations and almost everything is private due to developers and communities. It's tough fishing and pickerel are the rue of the land.