My year hasn't gotten much better since posting this- overall getting 1 keeper fish per 8 hours or none at all has been pretty standard for me this year with the exception being Cayuga where I had culled fish both days of our 2-day tourney and averaged over 3 lbs per fish. Cayuga is stupid easy though.
So in a calendar year, excluding the 2 days at Cayuga, I have landed 4 fish I could weigh in, in 56 hours of fishing. The Boaters I am with haven't really done much better- caught 8.
I have caught shorts, Perch, catfish, Pickerel though...