I'm in the process of getting either of these. What's everyone's preference? If I get a kayak, it'll have a trolling motor or peddle system. The John boat in looking at is 18 foot fairly new with fairly new mercury 4stroke 5hp, with trolling motor. The kayak would be around $1k, vs the boat is $2k.
Mind you, I'll be fishing all winter and was wondering how kayak fisherman deal with the seasonal effects.
Thanks for input.