The lake I fish the most holds big Bass, big Pickerel, and big Perch. If you fish this place during the daytime, except Sunday afternoons, you might come away believing it's sterile. During the week and Saturdays it seems almost impossible to catch anything except carp and bluegill. It's not impossible of course, but very close. Fish at at dusk and into the night and your reward might be great. It comes alive. You can absolutely hammer them. My group of hardcores that fish here consistently have been skunked and stumped as to why the daytime bite is so tough. We know better but still try. I've met so many daytime fisherman there who are not in my group that are totally frustrated. They're positive the lake is fished out. I thought about this subject for quite a while and have come to a conclusion: There's a major roadway that runs parallel to the length of the lake just outside the tree line. The traffic on this highway is non stop. There's an endless drumbeat of tires clipping expansion joints. You can feel it if you're on that side. This slows down dramatically at 7:30 pm. This also coincides with the bite turning on, for the most part, depending on a number of other factors. One night it could be 8:00 pm and the the next might be 9:10, and so on. Maybe this environmental noise factor represents one element of pressure the fish here have adapted to and shut down until it passes? But if you can put in those later hours, and are not spooked by being in the woods at night, the catch rate is great. The bite window shifts, but the bite can be awesome. If you catch one you'll probably catch more. They "seem" to come in and feed in waves, then recede in unison. There also "seems" to be a hot 40 minute window, then poof, they're gone. Please note the quotes around "seems", especially Tom(WRB). The other night my buddy had a gut feeling and hit it at 3:45 am and had a bonanza. This never happens during the day there for any of us and others AFAIK.
BTW, vibrating baits work great at night. Ribbon tail worms, paddletail swimmers, and chatterbaits do the best. Wakes and glides work too