While reorganizing my tackle, I got to thinking about my assortment of topwaters and their colors. Now I'll be the first to admit that color is at the bottom of my list when it comes to choosing baits. I adhere to the general guidelines about color, except for my topwaters. I've read, heard and even recommend that color really doesn't matter, just throw anything with a white or dark belly. the reason being the fish are looking up and the underside of a bait and that is what they see. So why do I have frog patterns, orange bellies, solid chrome and all the other colors and combinations of my favorite walking bait, the Zara Spook?
Two reasons; That bait can and does, call fish from a good distance away and not just from directly under it. From a side angle 15ft. away, a bass can surely see the sides of the bait. So if color can be an important factor with other hard baits, why wouldn't that also apply to topwaters? The other reason is that I rarely work a walking bait fast, so the fish gets a good look at it. As with other baits, if the fish aren't committing to a lure/presentation, I'll switch something. With me, it's usually cadence/speed or the size of the bait I'm using. Changing color is the last thing I will try, but it's the first when fishing on top. A switch to a frog pattern almost always results in solid hook-ups following explosive hits from fish that would only swirl at other offerings.
This realization has me rethinking my view of the importance of color for other applications. Nah, I'm an old fart that is resistant to change and has too much time on his hands during the off season.