I know this is a dead thread but you guys are overthinking it. The strange Gantarel colors like wounded shiner are just as productive and if you burn or twitch it, it’s more like a jerkbait thing, they don’t inspect it, they just crush it. Fishing it finesse during the spawn, you may want to get a realistic color and action but the Gantarels are produce best as a power presentation.
It’s how strangely and erratically that the lure behaves that draws them in. Think of it as a giant jerkbait.
Just wanted to add this for anyone googling or whatever and then browsing the thread to see.
thanks!