Wow I am in this same position as you. Waiting on tax money and considering the titan 10.5 or pa 12. I would also consider the titan 12 or 13.5. I have not tested any of them. I am not sure there is a place near me (Indiana) where I can demo. I am leaning towards the titan 10.5 because I think there is just enough room for me (6' 250lb), fishing gear, cooler, and my cocker spaniel. All others would have room to spare so i am not sure they are worth it. I had a perception pescador last year and vowed I would buy a pedal kayak this year. i will be following your decision with great interest!