Here's my update, if anyone cares to hear it ;D
I used the Preparation H before going to bed and woke up feeling better. Not totally better, but better.
That night, I had to go #2 and it was like ripping a scab off. Believe me, I DID NOT want to go. Used the medicine again a few more times and all seems to be getting better as the days pass.
I think I figured out what was wrong, aside from being extremely constipated. I had gone for a stress test and they injected me with a radioactive dye. I believe the injection caused me to be unusually constipated, thus causing me to overly push and develop a hemorrhoid. Anesthesia can and will cause your bowels to get all messed up.
Thanks for all the concern and I still plan on going to the doctor just as a precaution.