^ this was almost mine, exact same color, but in a 4".
Since I'm a multi-species guy, 3" Berkley Powerbait Power Grub in Pumpkin Seed or White. I can't pick one color over the other since one resembles a craw color and the other ties to shad. This grub on a jig has personally landed me smallies, bucketmouths, walleyes, saugeyes, channel cats, crappie, bluegill, rainbow trout, and white bass. It's so versatile within the water column. One can effectively work it as a search bait for suspended fish to or a slower, jigging presentation off riprap areas. The spectrum is so wide.
Honorable mention: 2.5 " Black Shad Gulp! Alive! Minnow on a chartreuse Roadrunner.