I like the layout and storage on the Tracker 175TXW better than the Ranger RT178. The ride will also be better on the Tracker which has a better designed hull. I think the finishing touches on the Ranger are better. The main components, steering, motor, trolling motor, batteries, aluminum, carpet, depth finder are all pretty much the same. Tracker is powder coated, a plus. Ranger has a better trailer. Tracker has a wood deck, Ranger has aluminum. Tracker has a recirculating livewell system standard. Ranger is an option. Both good boats and priced pretty close to the same.