Thank you everyone for your replies.
I should’ve been clearer that I’ve been fishing these ponds (3 in town) that are stocked with Channel cats and brown trout depending on the time of year. I love bass fishing but without the ~45 minute drive to Lake Mead that’s not an option.
Im going to take this advice and switch up what I’ve been using. I’ll try some night crawlers and grubs (one outing with crawlers in a pond produced nothing). I’ve never fished top water baits or a crank at all in my time here. Maybe something different.
As as I read more from the (few) online comments of people here in town, it becomes clear the urban ponds here get SO much pressure it likely makes them not worth it.
Mead, from all I’ve been told is not an easy place to fish from shore, but without a boat or yak, that’s what I’m going to have to try.
Maybe I will be skunked at Mead (likely, actually) but at least I’m trying some place new.
What was holding me back from trips was the thought of driving ~5 hours round trip up to Utah (for example) to get skunked. I guess I’ll have to just suck it up and be prepared to be disappointed. That would be REALLY hard to swallow though, and I’d likely not want to fish for a long time after that.